Playfulness with dark undercurrents from DOE

Fraser Riddell finds Durham Opera Ensemble’s Hansel and Gretel sugary-sweet while showcasing Durham’s top quality operatic talent

ENGELBERT HUMPERDINCK’S Hansel & Gretel presents the familiar folk-tale as a full-scale opera.

Premiered in 1893, it utilizes much of the style familiar from Richard Wagner’s music-dramas but melds it with material derived from German folk songs. Its sense of fun and youthfulness have ensured its enduring popularity in the opera-house.

Zoë Andrews’ production for Durham Opera Ensemble captured both the playfulness of the opera’s surface and the underlying darkness of the folk-tale’s subtext.

Sarah Shepherd and Julia Hudson were perfectly cast as Hansel and Gretel. While Hudson’s voice was far from the most powerful in the cast, her purity of tone captured the innocence of her character superbly. Shepherd’s more resonant mezzo provided a fine contrast to this, capturing the boyishness of her role.

Gillian Plummer’s (Mother) voice penetrated the dense orchestral texture easily and Michael Bunch (Father) displayed a fine control of the higher register in his flexible bass voice.

Harriet Fisher clearly relished her role as the Witch, her voice simultaneously mellifluous and rather disturbing! For a group of such talented singers, the cast could have relied on their own abilities to a greater extent: too great a reliance on the conductor for cues occasionally shattered the dramatic illusion.

Andrews presented a chorus of zombies, providing a relieving counterpoint to the sometimes cloying sugar-sweetness of this opera, and often the effective positioning of the group ensured a stirring ‘surround-sound’ experience.

Unfortunately the performance of the chorus was not matched by the corps de ballet. While Claire Hall’s choreography was certainly ambitious, it seemed to stretch the skills of her dancers rather too far. Despite some convincing performances, there was a general lack of synchronization and often an inability to follow the musical pulse precisely. It often felt as though Andrews could have trusted the power of the music to carry the emotional force of the drama, rather than crowding the stage with these rather unremarkable interludes.

Under the baton of Tom Newall, the orchestra were more than capable of commanding the attention of the audience throughout. It is tempting to take the musical abilities of these players for granted, yet their rigorous but subtle approach to elements of phrasing and ensemble underpinned the success of the production as a whole.

A common criticism of opera performed in English – rather than in the original language supplemented with subtitles – is the inability to hear the words clearly. This production used an English translation of the original German libretto. While the diction of the singers was universally crisp and precise, there were inevitably occasions when, due to balance issues between stage and orchestra, the words were lost. What impressed most, however, was the manner in which the strength of the physical acting conveyed perfectly the sense of the libretto.

This production had a sense of youthful ebullience rare in the professional opera-house. An opera of this scale is a truly ambitious project and DOE succeeded in presenting an evening which showcased outstanding vocal, orchestral and theatrical talent.