Personality trumps policy in Mair’s interview with Boris Johnson

by Daisy-Rose Srblin
Variously described by the papers as a ‘bicycle crash’ and a political ‘skewering’, Eddie Mair’s interview with Boris Johnson last week has sparked debate regarding the integrity of both journalistic practice and politics itself. Standing in for Andrew Marr, Mair questioned Johnson about the content of the recent BBC documentary, ‘Boris Johnson: The Irresistible Rise’.
Press coverage has varied according to political affiliation, as Johnson’s enemies celebrated the interview as ‘career ending’ while others accused the BBC of poor journalism. Johnson’s flustered responses to controversial aspects of his past and private life are seen by some as having jeopardised the London Mayor’s future chances of becoming Conservative leader.
But viewing the interview from the perspective of a public relations blunder inflates the real political damage done. While The Mirror understood the interview as having exposed the ‘lying, cheating, untrustworthy egomaniac’, the apparent ‘revelations’ were rather underwhelming. The first was that Johnson had ‘lied’ in a piece while a journalist at The Times, though, rather less excitingly, the example was a misattributed event which took place over seven centuries ago in the life of Piers Gaveston, Edward II’s possible lover. The second more serious matter concerned Johnson’s dismissal from Michael Howard’s shadow cabinet following his denial of an extra-marital affair, though Johnson certainly paid the price for the furore and continues to dispute that he lied directly to Howard. Johnson’s private conduct is overwhelmingly his own concern, understood even by David Cameron who chose not to sack him despite his second affair in 2006.
Finally, his taped conversation with convicted fraudster Darius Guppy, a friend from Oxford, in which Johnson promised to supply the home address of a journalist that had been irritating Guppy for the purposes of beating up the journalist, was also cited. All of this was said by Mair to be conclusive evidence that Johnson was a ‘nasty piece of work’. However, the conversation in question took place over twenty years ago and it was noted that the address was never supplied by Johnson and the journalist in question never harmed.
More importantly still, the fact that Johnson has been able to make such a successful political career for himself seems to be evidence of our tendency to respect charisma and charm over diligence and honesty in politics. In the BBC’s documentary ‘The Irresistible Rise’, journalist Ian Hislop described Johnson as the one ‘feel-good politician’ left in the otherwise dark days of economic hardship and vanishing faith in political structures. Certainly antics like Johnson’s publicity stunt on a zip-wire in a suit in promotion of the Olympic games have given him a bumbling and loveable image which eludes the Camerons and Milibands of British politics.It should be more than clear that Johnson’s integrity was not the real issue here.
However, what these discussions do point to is a significant area of contention regarding what it is we expect from our politicians. The fact that politicians’ private lives are currently meddled in by the press as if they were fair game (The Sun’s revelations concerning ‘bonking Boris’ come to mind) suggest that we seem to hold our political representatives to an unattainable ideal that we ourselves cannot reach, expecting a faultless past and spotless record. But in doing so we ignore the harsh realities of the ‘greasy pole’, the necessary arrogance, single-mindedness and ruthlessness required for political success. Events of Johnson’s past are not evidence of a nasty and sordid character making him embarrassingly unfit for public office, but rather the required political battle scars which are surely shared by his colleagues.
However, charisma and charm are no substitute for political content. Mair’s interview should have been widely circulated because of its discussion of Conservative immigration policy which in many ways threatens to further exacerbate the disproportionate political attention given to immigration, particularly in this period of recession and in the spirit of scapegoating. Further, not only is such policy designed to ‘reduce the pull factors’ of Britain’s opportunities for people seeking to come here, the policy seeks to target those ‘leaching’ on the state, linking also to the reactionary mentality behind the government’s welfare cuts.
Political scrutiny is crucial to a healthy representative democracy, but such checks on power should focus upon content and policy over the seemingly more entertaining search for a colourful past. Political intention matters more than ever and wariness should be employed against the creation of ‘political celebrity’ as a form of escapism most importantly at a time of significant economic instability.
Photograph: Annie Mole
