Perception and reality: women in the workplace

by Rachael Revesz

The 8th of March 2011 marked the centenary of International Women’s Day.  Now 35 years on from the Sex Discrimination Act and 40 years on from the Equal Pay Act, women currently make up almost half of the workforce.

Yet according to a recent Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) report, women are still facing severe discrimination in the workplace.  It also revealed that fewer industries that can boast a more distinct lack of gender equality than that in the finance sector, which employs around 4% of the workforce and a significantly higher proportion of Durham students. (Of those who entered employment, 23.4% of males but only 12.9% of females went into a finance-related job after completion of their first degree in 2009). Indeed, it was feared that these inequalities in terms of salary and promotion had been exacerbated during the financial crisis. More worryingly, the EHRC’s latest report on gender inequality in the finance sector showed that there was little, if any, proof of improvement.

But not all women have become another statistic. Galia Loya, currently a Managing Director at Goldman Sachs, works with both men and women on a daily basis.

“I haven’t been interviewed since I left Durham,” she tells me.

The international powerhouse that is Goldman Sachs suffered a spate of bad press in September of last year, after former Managing Director of the Fixed Income Currency and Commodity department, Nomi Prins, reported her negative experiences to the American news website The Daily Beast. She declared that although Goldman Sachs did not “overtly discriminate” against women, the lack of gender equality was clear as one looked around the boardroom.

“The perception that some people have of investment banking – the aggressive, male-dominated environment, for example – is completely different from the reality”, argues Galia Loya, a Securities Division MD in Fleet Street. “Until people experience it for themselves, they won’t realise how wrong they are.”

Galia graduated from Durham University in 1998 with a degree in Classics and two weeks later, was sent to New York for her Goldman Sachs training course. After three years in Asian Equities and four years as a global tech specialist, Galia moved into European Equities, her current department, where she is now Managing Director. But is it hard for a woman at the top?

“Men and women have different personalities, of course, but we all work as a team. I have always worked with both men and women, in the office and from my client side, too.

“We target women at a younger age; for example we have a programme for A-level school girls. They come and spend time with us and realise that banking is so different from what they had imagined.”

But even Galia can’t deny that, as with most global corporations, there is a distinct diminution of female presence the higher up the ladder one goes.

 “Whereas the firm makes efforts to hire a nearly equal percentage of women at the junior level, those percentages drop dramatically at the more senior ranks,” Nomi Prins tells Palatinate. “This is a particularly prevalent phenomenon of the finance sector as a whole.”

 So, following on from Nomi’s words, despite all the targeting and promoting of female candidates, what about the retaining of them?

 “We organise lots of networking events and training programmes where women get to meet fellow women colleagues. There is a lot to get involved in. I am also a mentor – again, for both men and women. There are people who seek me out for advice and I’m more than happy to fill that role.”

 The peachy land of equality that apparently is Goldman Sachs seems to be an exception, according to the EHRC report, which collected data from 50 top financial institutions in the UK.  The average gap in annual gross earnings is an incredible 60% (compared with an average 42% in other sectors) and much of this differentiation is concentrated in bonus packages. The report found that those who were most likely to receive a boost to their pay packet were those who were more ready to ask for it.  Goldman Sachs employees are reportedly amongst those earning in the top bracket. Galia, however, is not willing to discuss her earnings.

 “Goldman Sachs is a merit-based organisation. That means you are given a platform and it is up to you how far you get.”

And it isn’t just the finance sector which faces accusations of gender inequality.

“In addition, there are fewer women, comparably, in senior economic positions in governments, central banks, and international institutions such as the IMF, IFC, and Worldbank – all of which are run by men,” Nomi tells us.

It seems that the perception and reality of women in the workplace are still worlds apart.

But Galia is quick to reassure me.

“Goldman Sachs is a fabulous place to work.”