People of Abandoned Character Vs. The Five: Dignity in True Crime

By Holly Hughes-Rowlands

Over the summer, I read two books about the Jack the Ripper murders. People of Abandoned Character by Claire Whitfield, a novel telling the fictional story of Susannah Chapman, a lower middle class nurse whose marriage deteriorates into abuse as she starts to suspect him of being the Ripper; and The Five by Hallie Rubenhold, a nonfiction history of the victims’ lives. In this article, I intend to compare their treatment of those five women. How one prioritises their lives and their dignity, while the other exploits their deaths to serve a fictional narrative. 

The two books do belong to very different genres, and so I am not comparing their overall quality, as that would be an unfair comparison. I am focusing on their portrayals of the real victims.

People of Abandoned Character was a disappointment for me in general, but especially so in its treatment of the historical victims. The novel reduces them to their deaths in a way I consider to be exploitative. Their murders are little more than plot markers.

The protagonist’s narration is also quite judgemental and damning working-class women and often (possibly unintentionally) implies they are at fault for their living situations. The author gives little sympathy in the narrative to these women, which, considering that all the Ripper’s victims were working class women, removes them from their own history in favour of a middle-class protagonist.

The author gives little sympathy in the narrative to these women, which, considering that all the Ripper’s victims were working class women, removes them from their own history in favour of a middle-class protagonist.

The book is at its worst in its treatment of Mary Kelly, the final victim. At the end of the book, it is revealed that (in this version of the tale) the murders were being committed by a group taking the organs of the victims to sell on the black market, and that Mary Kelly had been working with this group to “lure innocents” to their deaths. Then, when she and the main villain must escape the country, they blackmail the protagonist into helping them fake Mary’s death. They “mutilate” another corpse, so the authorities don’t recognise it is not Mary. This is described in immense detail, including actual things done to the real Mary Kelly’s body by the real murderer. 

It has been over a hundred years since Mary Kelly’s death, and yet, given the way it has been dragged out again and again in front of audiences across the world, I cannot help but be offended on her behalf. Not only is she removed from her own life and death in the novel, but she is robbed of her dignity. She is made complicit in the deaths of the others whilst the details of her most vulnerable moment; and the things done to her in it; are shared and picked over. The real Mary is absent in a novel re-telling her death; replaced by the presence of her killer.  As this is fiction, it is the author’s right to tell the story as she wants. However, I think we should question using the murder of a real person to serve a fictional narrative. 

The Five is a non-fiction account of the lives of the ripper’s victims, so one could argue it is unfair of me to compare it to People of Abandoned Character. However, the care and respect with which Hallie Rubenhold re-centres the lives, loves and woes of these women was so opposite in tone to their portrayal in People of Abandoned Character that I had to bring it up as a counter example. In the five, it is Polly, Annie, Kate, Elizabeth, and Mary Jane that take centre stage, and their stories are fascinating. For example, despite the popular image of Jack the Ripper as a killer of prostitutes, there is only evidence to suggest two of them were ever sex workers. Mary Jane lived in Paris for several years. Polly and Annie had children from whom they were estranged; and Kate wrote and sold ballads and songs whilst travelling the country with her husband and children. The murderer exists so far on the fringes of this book that I often forgot how the five’s stories were going end. It is a true achievement, a challenge to dominant misogynistic narratives and a masterpiece of nonfiction historical literature.

How many times can someone’s violent death be shown, told, and sensationalised for entertainment before it becomes exploitative?

True Crime is an immensely popular genre, and one that is also controversial. How many times can someone’s violent death be shown, told, and sensationalised for entertainment before it becomes exploitative? Netflix has recently come under harsh criticism for its show Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story. Though lead actor Evan Peters has said that the show is about the victims and people affected by the murders, the show’s title and content might suggest different. Dahmer is still centre stage in the advertising, the title, and in many of the episodes. In addition, the victim’s families were reportedly not consulted about the show’s content, despite many of them being featured in it. Is it right for them to have to relive this trauma again and again without warning? All for the sake of entertainment.

I am not condemning an interest in true crime. I enjoy it myself. But I do think that the genre tends to ignore the victims for the sake of sensationalising the murderer. It is not fair to the victims or their families to continue to deprive them of their dignity in retellings, while using their murderer to create excitement.

As Hallie Rubenhold concludes in The Five, “In order to keep [the ripper] alive, we have had to forget his victims. We have become complicit in their diminishment. 

[…] It is only by bringing these women back to life that we can silence the ripper and what he represents. By permitting them to speak, by attempting to understand their experiences and see their humanity, we can restore to them the respect and compassion to which they are entitled.”

Image credit: Ari Spada via Unsplash