Peace on the cards in Ukraine: but to whose advantage?
By Truitt Burkes
It will soon mark 4 years since Vladimir Putin ordered the first Russian tanks into Luhansk and began his full-scale invasion of Ukraine. In the time that has followed, international organisations, states, and corporate actors have openly opposed the conflict. Yet many of their practical responses remain overly cautious, revealing a wariness about confronting Russia’s political leadership and military head-on. Since his re-election in 2024, US President Donald Trump’s strategy has vehemently challenged this approach and taken an aggressive stance to establish peace in the region. Last week, in a bold move of diplomacy, Trump unveiled a draft of his new 28-point peace plan, providing both Russia and Ukraine a detailed roadmap for peace. Although Putin has since approved the scheme, Trump is putting increasing pressure on the Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy to accept the proposal as well.
In the plan, Trump outlines a set of 28 provisions to guide Russia and Ukraine towards a seemingly more harmonious co-existence. However, many have noted that the deal appears skewed and blatantly favours Moscow’s interests, including Zelenskyy himself. Although Trump confirms that Ukraine will retain its political sovereignty, “receive reliable security guarantees”, and be given “a powerful global package of measures to rebuild”, much of the other conditions detail a strict crackdown on its defensive capabilities and a cession of Ukrainian territory to Russia. Under the plan, “Crimea, Luhansk and Donetsk will be recognized as de facto Russian, including by the United States”, with the size of the “Ukrainian Armed Forces limited to 600,000 personnel”. The proposal also states that not only will Ukraine be barred from joining NATO, but must also agree to “enshrine in its constitution” a commitment to never do so in the future. Russia’s few demands include a £100 billion payout to fund rebuilding efforts in Ukraine and a commitment to a “comprehensive, non-aggression agreement”. However, it will also gain sanction relief, economic reintegration, and a renewed invitation to join the G8, from which it was suspended following its annexation of Crimea in 2014.
Many have noted that the deal appears skewed and blatantly favours Moscow’s interests
Moscow is also helped by the fact that Trump has given Zelenskyy a deadline, this coming Thursday, to accept his plan. Outside the presidential palace on Friday, the Ukrainian president voiced his concerns about the latest proposal to end the war. “Ukraine may find itself making a very difficult choice: either the loss of dignity or the risk of losing a key partner”, he said, referring to the United States. In his speech, the former comedian–turned–president admitted that if he were to reject Washington’s plan, Ukrainians would face “the most difficult winter” to date. Yet his response stopped short of committing to the agreement, leaving it uncertain how he plans to proceed. Accepting the plan’s conditions could be beneficial as Ukraine would be guaranteed a ceasefire alongside billions of dollars of aid. With Russia continuing to make gains in eastern Ukraine, this could be an opportunity for Zelenskyy to secure a ceasefire without an outright admission of defeat. But he would willingly risk ceding over 10% of the country’s territory to a nation that has consistently shown little respect for international law.
European leaders have openly critiqued Trump’s plan to the point where an alternative 28-point counterproposal has been issued. On Sunday, European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen warned of the document’s pro-Russian bias and expressed concern that Europe was left out of discussions on achieving a peaceful resolution to the conflict. The counterproposal, drafted by Britain, Germany, and France, uses the US plan as its basis yet differs markedly from Trump’s vision. Under the European plan, negotiations would “start from the Line of Contact”, contrasting with the US plan, which predetermined territorial concessions. It would also increase Ukraine’s military capacity to 800,000 and leave NATO membership open as a future possibility. Zelenskyy may have more flexibility than it appears, and aligning with Trump’s proposed plan is far from the guaranteed path towards both security and peace.
Image: Presidential Press and Information Office via Wikimedia Commons

