‘Pay Drivers’: F1’s dirty secret

by Lawrence Holmes
If asked to name two current British Formula 1 drivers, most F1 fans would jump immediately to Lewis Hamilton and Jenson Button.
Both have won World Championships, and have 37 career race wins between them. However, it is Paul di Resta and Max Chilton, the two other British drivers, that best epitomise a darker side of the sport.
Scottish F1 driver Paul di Resta’s future at Force India is uncertain according to his manager, Richard Goddard. Admittedly, it is impossible to argue that di Resta is having a hugely successful season.
His form has plummeted in the second half of the season, having previously recorded six consecutive points finishes in the first half.
He last finished in the points at Silverstone, placing 9th, and since then has been forced to retire in five consecutive races: Hungary, Belgium, Italy, Singapore and Korea.
And yet, Goddard is convinced that it is not form (di Resta is after all, a hugely talented and promising driver) but money that is leading Force India to question his worthiness of a seat in their team.
Di Resta brings with him little sponsorship, and in a sport that costs teams so much to compete in, this is a crippling disadvantage for the 27-year old Scot.
At the other end of the sponsorship spectrum we have Max Chilton. The 21-year old driver has undoubted ability, but ultimately his seat at Marussia rests on the large amount of sponsorship he brings with him.
Chilton’s predecessor at Marussia, Timo Glock, was released from his contract for “commercial” reasons.
This system of ‘pay drivers’, whereby less-talented drivers can secure a seat by agreeing to drive for a team for free (or at least on a much lower salary) as well as by providing the team with a large amount of sponsorship revenue, threatens talented drivers like di Resta and Glock who lack the economic clout of others but whose talent warrants a drive.
The system is much more widespread than many appreciate. Sergio Perez, currently driving for McLaren alongside Button, was ultimately able to enter the sport and drive for Sauber in 2011 due to having wealthy Mexican backers.
What’s more, McLaren’s decision to appoint Perez was at least partly driven by the economic boost his sponsorship would provide, choosing him over more previously successful drivers.
Other big-name drivers whose claim to seats have been strengthened considerably by sponsors include Pastor Maldonado, backed by a Venezuelan oil supplier, Vitalay Petrov, who holds a variety of sponsors including Flagship, a Russian vodka company, and Vyborg Shipyard, and 5-time World Champion Juan Manuel Fangio, who received considerable financial support from the Argentine government of the time.
The boundaries between ‘pay drivers’ and other drivers selected for their ability are blurred. The examples above exemplify this: they are by no means bad drivers, with Fangio one of the sport’s all-time greats. Nonetheless, the power of money in Formula 1 cannot be underestimated.
‘Pay drivers’ still have to perform, as ultimately, race wins are just as lucrative as the largest sponsorship deals. It is not a simple black and white case of ‘bad’ drivers paying themselves into the sport at the cost of better, poorer drivers.
In Formula 1 more than anywhere, money talks. In the words of Trevor Carlin, team principle of Chilton’s former GP2 team Carlin, “with very few exceptions, Formula 1 is not a poor man’s sport.”
Photograph: Nic Redhead
