Year Abroad: Paris of the Middle East

By Seun Onabolu

Paris of the Middle East 300x200

Entirely foreign to the region and as a stranger to the less economically developed world, my arrival in Beirut is best characterised by discomfort – discomfort that perhaps I ought to have been prepared for or at least to have expected from a move to a so famously unsettled land. But clouded by ignorance and deluded by optimism, I had naively (perhaps unforgivably) made no effort to even consider the meaning of those nuances suggested within Beirut’s mercilessly repeated slogan, “The Paris of the Middle East” – and instead I had rather understood from those words something more akin to Paris in the Middle East – a view which, of course, I now treat as great misjudgement.

Perhaps, like the Paris of the Enlightenment, Beirut ought to be considered the pioneer amongst an Arab fleet – a pioneer in the protection of human rights, religious pluralism, and freedom of expression in a region that is yet to address many of these fundamental socio-political issues. Rather, I cannot help but feel that if Beirut is indeed a pioneering Middle Eastern city in any aspect of its development then it must be navigating blindly. Clumsily unaware of its weight Lebanese society seems to find itself where it is by chance without any control over its course. Unsurprisingly then, it is constantly unsettled, ever unsure, even when it finds itself in pleasant waters.

Superficiality is that deep foundation upon which Lebanon now builds itself – an impenetrable facade which, upon its discovery, leaves us at best in dismay, otherwise utterly confounded. Only on so fictitious a foundation could a Paris be built in the region. It is commonplace knowledge that the house built on sand repeatedly suffers spoil at the indiscriminate hand of the sea, and the well- known consequence of such commonplace error is so brutally evident in Beiruti society. As such, what is of real interest is the cause of such ignorance in a society that is surely now old enough to make its own way. If not from mistakes, then from what will it learn?

For example, the woman’s apparent freedom to dress as she wishes has somehow almost been enough to see the surrender of her voice – her surrender, whether it be because of ignorance or because of despair, being far more sorrowful an image than her denial. So widespread across all strata of society here is a viciously false misconception: that such a small (and yet so seemingly large) freedom is exchangeable for or even equivalent to the enjoyment of equal rights – which the Lebanese woman is most certainly not afforded. I hasten to add that the woman’s plight is but one of several discrepancies in this place.

The seemingly honourable title of “The Paris of the Middle East” is surely, verily, and solely a lingering relic of colonialist France. The confusion of a rude interruption and unfinished statement plagues Lebanese society with diffraction. The same thorough misjudgement that I am now ashamed to have made before my arrival is pitifully commonplace misunderstanding amongst the greater population here. The consequent sui generis cultural identity (or lack thereof) is woefully ridiculous and comically absurd. In every sense engulfed in unrest and with friction at its borders with Israel in the south and Syria, Lebanon’s crisis is much more than its post-colonial identity issue. Surely, as the capital of a state which is half the size of Wales but whose problematic presence far exceeds its size, Beirut ought to have long ago unshackled itself from that patronising and submissive linking with France.

Photograph: Seun Onabolu