Palatinate interviews Noam Chomsky
Professor Noam Chomsky of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) recently sat down with Palatinate News Editor Justin Villamil for an exclusive interview.
Professor Chomsky is an American linguist and political activist who has authored over 100 books and has made significant contributions to the fields of both linguistic theory and political science.
A leading political critic, Professor Chomsky sat down with Palatinate to discuss his views on the corporatisation of universities, the European elections, and how casual comments about Scotland have been misconstrued by the press.
The following is a transcript of this interview.
You’ve spoken a lot about the corporatisation of universities, specifically in the United States. We’ve seen a similar trend in the UK. What do you think a university should do in order to properly fulfill the purpose of education?
You have to decide what the purpose of education is. There are traditional views on the matter that go back to the Enlightenment. In fact, during the Enlightenment there were two major visions presented, one negatively, the other positively. The negative vision used the image of filling a vessel with water and then testing to see if the water was in there. The second vision is creating and developing opportunities to inquire and create. That is, that teaching should be like laying out a string along which the student proceeds in his or her own way, maybe moving it along the way. So some form of structure, but encouraging independent forms of thought, discovering who you are, creating, inquiring, developing yourself in some capacity. These are two very different pictures. The first one is the one that is preferred by administrators, the business world and so on. They want people to be trained to be passive, obedient, skilled in the specific tasks they’re asked to perform. Corporatization of universities drives things in that direction. Teaching the test is the standard framework.
I take it you’re more inclined toward the second perspective.
Obviously (laughs). It’s kind of interesting because it is differentiated. So if you take a look at the way the educational system is actually being driven, a lot of it is towards filling the vessel with water, testing what’s there. But not in science. If you go to a place like where I teach, MIT, a leading science institution, it’s not at all like that, and there’s a good reason for that – the sciences would die. Science students are supposed to challenge. The standard line is it doesn’t matter what you cover in class, it matters what you discover by yourself. You have to learn how to think, how to create and challenge and explore new directions – otherwise the fields will just die.
Is there anything a university can do to encourage that in a non-science subject?
Sure, we can struggle against these tendencies. I mean, what’s happening in England is worse even than what’s happening in the United States.
How so?
I mean, you may have seen some interesting articles by Stefan Collini in the London Review of Books where the bottom line was that the Tory government is trying to turn, as he put it ‘first class universities into third-class commercial enterprises’. And you see it all the time. Recently I had to write a recommendation for a former student for a fellowship award in England; he happens to be a philosopher. He was working on a couple of very interesting questions on the cutting edge of philosophical analysis, and one of the questions was ‘what will his research contribute to the economy of England?’ Right? That’s, well, that’s demeaning. And you can see it, it’s showing up in all sorts of ways. In the US there’s a committee in the House of Representatives that supervises the National Science Foundation, which gives grants across the spectrum for research. They’ve recently instituted a requirement that in political science all grants have to be provided to work that either supports defense or the economy. Nothing else.
What is the role of a student in all of this? You‘ve previously spoken about the debt burden students face and how it locks us into a competitive, capitalist structure. Is there a way for students to take a high-paying job and still live a moral, ethical life, for example?
It’s not easy. It’s very difficult. There’s kind of an anecdote at Harvard Law School, which answers the question. Students come in wearing jeans and backpacks and planning to go into public interest law and human rights work and so on. April comes around and corporate recruiters come to offer positions for the summer and a student thinks okay, I’ll take a couple months and work for this corporate law firm and then I’ll come back to do whatever I want to do. September, when they come back, it’s suits and jackets, forgetting the public interest; they go on into the corporate law firm world. It’s tempting when you’re inside it, and that’s the goal. The idea is you’re trapped by debt, and then you move in directions that will pay off. You become coopted by those opportunities and amenities that go along with it. It doesn’t have to happen, but the tendencies are quite strong and understandable.
I’d like to change tracks a bit. Several weeks ago you caused a stir when you spoke in favor of the independence of Scotland. Have you had a chance to revisit the issue?
That’s an interesting comment on the British media. I was asked what I thought about the independence of Scotland, and I said it’s a complex issue that I hadn’t really studied in any depth, and I couldn’t really take a position on it. But my instinct would be in favor of autonomy, generally, not in this case, but in all cases. And that’s all that survived, not the first part. But no, officially I’m not taking a stand on the matter. Journalism has its own filters.
You’ve written before in favor of a ‘devolution of power.’ As voters go into the polls today for the European elections, is there anything that you think they should know?
Well, I’m not really opposed to large-scale structure and the direction in which Europe is moving – there are a lot of positive things there. For example, the Schengen Agreements, the movements across borders, that’s a very good thing – anything that would scrap borders. In fact, there’s been a remarkable transition in Europe since the Second World War. For centuries, Europe was the most savage place in the world as nation-state systems were imposed; they tried to impose themselves on others. One of the main commitments of Europeans was to slaughter each other, and this goes far back.
For example, the Thirty Years War probably killed off a third of the population of Germany. By 1945 it had reached the point at which, if the Europeans had continued to play their favorite game they would have wiped everyone out. So there was a movement after that in a new direction towards integration of Europe, erosion of boundaries, freeing of interchange – these things are all good. On the other hand, there is centralisation of authority that goes along with it, and that’s not very good. Democracy has been severely undermined in Europe. The Wall Street Journal recently observed that if you take a look at European governments, they can go from far left to far right but they follow the same policies. Because the policies are coming from Brussels, meaning that the people in the countries following these policies have very little say about it. Coming from Brussels with the Bundesbank in the background – the Wall Street Journal didn’t say that but I’m adding it.
The extent to which this has gone is pretty remarkable. You may recall that a couple years ago the Greek Prime Minister Papandreou meekly suggested that there might be a referendum in Greece for the people to express an opinion as to whether they wanted to follow the orders from Brussels. He was bitterly condemned across the spectrum. I mean, how dare you suggest that the people should have an opinion on the policies the government should follow? It’s none of their business; this is to be determined by the bureaucrats in Brussels and the forces behind them, bankers and so on. That’s a negative aspect of the integration. There is a reaction to this centralisation, and it is towards a kind of devolution to local authority. Actually, the Scottish autonomy referendum is part of this, and you see it particularly in Spain. There may be a referendum in Catalonia, and the Basque Country is fairly autonomous. It’s happening elsewhere – there’s a revival of local languages, cultures, traditions, and that’s all positive. So it’s kind of a mixed story, I don’t think it’s either good or bad.
For England to pull out of the European Union I think would be quite harmful. It would be a mistake. On the other hand, to accept the centralisation of authority would also be a mistake. The character is what’s important. The integration itself is a fine thing, but what matters is the form that it takes.
Even considering the devolution of power that would accompany a UK exit from the EU?
Yes. Devolution is not good or bad in itself. It depends on the form it takes. A devolution can have negative aspects. So for example, take, say, Catalonia. I happened to visit Catalonia right after Franco died. If you walked down the streets of Barcelona you didn’t hear a word of Catalan. All you heard was Spanish, there were no signs of Catalan culture, just Spanish. Catalan culture, language, and society had been bitterly suppressed under the Franco era. I went back about ten years later, and all you hear now is Catalan. I happened to be in a hotel overlooking the main square. There was a cathedral and so on and on Sunday morning, people were streaming into the square, musicians sitting on the steps of the cathedral playing folk music, people dancing to folk songs – it was a cultural revival. All of that is positive. On the other hand, there are elements of racism against Spanish workers. That’s a bad thing. So life’s not simple, basically.
Obviously you’re coming at this from a linguistic background – in reference to what you’re saying about Catalan, what kind of interplay do you see in Europe between language and politics?
There’s certainly a close connection between language and cultural revival. A language is not just a set of words; it’s a repository of history, culture, oral tradition, all sorts of things. If it’s lost, you’ve lost that cultural wealth. And in fact in Europe, over a long period, languages have been disappearing at a very rapid rate. Part of the process of state formation that has taken place for centuries in Europe is molding people of varied cultures, perspectives, languages, and molding them into a single, fixed mold. That’s part of state formation, and one aspect of it is the disappearance of languages. It’s happened at different rates in different parts of Europe.
Now, for example, in Italy there are plenty of people who can’t talk to their grandmother because they speak different languages. They’re called ‘Italian dialects’ but they’re really different languages. In France it happened not long before. It’s happening in Germany. Just to illustrate: a student of mine got his PhD in Linguistics at MIT and was working on German, and wanted to live in Germany for a couple of years. So he got himself a job in Cologne teaching German to Germans, the language that the young people spoke in Cologne was a variety of German but not standard German. They had to learn German as a second language. That’s not true anymore. It’s part of the loss of the linguistic and cultural variety of Europe. But it’s also reviving, as I mentioned in the Catalan case. So there’s a tendency in both directions.
Tonight you’re giving a talk closer to the political side of things. What is your current area of focus?
It’s schizophrenic, as it has been all my life (laughs). In fact, this visit illustrates the schizophrenia. Last night I gave a talk on linguistics in philosophy, this evening I’ll be giving a talk on public affairs, the future of the world, and so on.
And now I have to ask – are you enjoying Durham?
I’ve been enjoying the castle! I wish my grandchildren were here. They’d be playing Harry Potter games (laughs).
Image courtesy of Anna Rømcke Høiseth

