Paintings and pounds: money in the art world

8008925919_bb34c8ff57_o
Gerhard Richter’s abstract painting

By Holly Bancroft

300 million dollars. Can you envisage 300 million dollars? Well apparently it looks like ‘When Will You Marry?’ by Paul Gauguin. Sold on the 5th of February it became the world’s most expensive painting, just pipping Cezanne’s ‘The Card Players’, which sold for $274 million raising the question of whether the art market has become too money-centric.

It is to be expected that high-end art should become so highly valued. The pieces are one-off. We are dealing with a pool of work which is severely limited as the majority of the art in the market has been created by artists long dead. Yet precisely because of its unique nature surely this art should be available for all: not just those who can afford it.

February was a month for record-breaking art sales as Gerhard Richter’s ‘Abstraktes Bild’ sold for £30.4 million which set a new record for the German painter. In the same night at Sotheby’s, £8.4 million was paid for Lucio Fontana’s canvas which has been slashed by the artist 23 times. For the buyer of this piece, owning a prime example of Fontana’s Spazialismo movement would be hugely exciting. The piece achieves a unity of science and art as the peeling canvas is projected into the space, creating body out of the negative. For other cynical people, someone has just spent £8.4 million on 23 cuts in a piece of canvas. It is exactly this tension that makes the art market so controversial.

16170172448_331ff00b2e_o
‘When Will You Marry?’ by Paul Gauguin

The common argument against such unimaginable luxury is that the money could have been used for something else. However proponents of this view need to accept that if this money wasn’t being spent on art it would be spent on other material possessions. It is not a choice between Gauguin’s ‘When Will You Marry?’ or thousands saved through donations to an Ebola appeal. If you type 300 million dollars into Google you get a rather attractive video tour of Andrey Melnichenck’s 394-foot mega-yacht. The rich are getting richer and so prices for art will keep going up and up. Whether the art industry becomes categorised by this influx of money is a different issue entirely. The issue becomes especially prevalent when the industry becomes stagnated in buying and selling of old works rather than making space for new artists to emerge.

However just because art is begin bought by individuals does not mean that it is remains behind closed doors. Gauguin’s painting up until now had been on loan to Kunstmuseum in Basel, Switzerland from Rudolf Staechelin, who has now sold it. For Straechelin, art is a balance between his collection being available for viewing and financial security. He told the Times that he sold the Gauguin piece “mainly because we got a good offer. The market is very high and who knows what it will be in 10 years. I always tried to keep as much together as I could [but] over ninety percent of our assets are paintings hanging for free in the museum. It’s not a healthy financial risk distribution… For me they are family history and art. But they are also security and investments.” This sums up the problem with private collectors: yes some of them do allow their collections to be available to the public but many don’t. Ultimately the process of buying and selling will always catch up with a piece as people seek financial security or simply get bored with their purchase and sell it on.

If we truly appreciated a piece of art we would label it priceless, as too important to lock away in private collections which have no connection to the original artists. People convince themselves that by paying millions of dollars for something, they must love it a lot. But ultimately the most loving thing to do with these pieces is to gift them to foundations and galleries who will look after them – and not, as Steve Wynn did with Picasso’s ‘La Rene’, accidentally put their elbows through it. As we cannot know what dead artists wanted this is the most neutral, generous and caring thing we can do.

Images: Flickr ID: GBo GBo and Lia Mo