Outdated, offensive or educational? 

By Lauren James

Should we read controversial books? Is there value in reading literature with dated themes? 

Like all pieces of the past, controversial books hold invaluable history and lessons within them. There is a reason they are written, there are often fruitful debates to engage in and our natural feelings towards them show us something about human nature themselves. Why are they controversial? Not always for the right reason. Once something is written, it holds inherent value and hidden meanings which, nobody has the right to upend, mistreat, or simply deem as not worth reading. 

Still, certain books must be read with more caution than others and controversy is quite often legitimately founded. To dismiss this would, again, be a disservice to history and the knowledge that can be gleamed from such things. The book industry has struggled with these questions since it began. Throughout history different books have been banned and deemed ‘controversial’ for a range of reasons and not everybody always agreed with these bans. There have been groups and individuals who read these books in protest, whilst others have campaigned for books to be banned despite their enjoyment by others. Today, it is no different, except that there is a bigger platform for polarising opinions, accessible 24/7 around the world via the internet, and a bigger push for both freedom of speech and defending people’s opinions, all set against a background of increasing worries over censorship from both political ends.

Certain books must be read with more caution than others and controversy is quite often legitimately founded. To dismiss this would, again, be a disservice to history and the knowledge that can be gleamed from such things

Taking a look at books that were once controversial and deemed inappropriate for the wider public to read, and are now not, is one way to explore the question of whether we should be reading controversial books today – as it illuminates some of the reasons they were both banned and made publicly accessible again. Some of these issues (from religious disagreement to worry over sexually explicit content) will no doubt be similar to ones that communities face today and so exploring the discourse around these books can be beneficial towards dealing with them in the future.

One example of a book once deemed controversial is Lady Chatterley’s Lover by D.H. Lawrence, written between 1926 and 1928. This novel was seen as unnecessarily sexually graphic and immoral in a British society which saw sex as a private matter within the sanctity of marriage. The book’s focus on a woman who had an affair due to a lack of sex in her marriage, and the message that marriage would not survive without physical intimacy in conjunction with emotional intimacy, both shocked and offended many readers – with the publishers even facing a landmark obscenity trial when the full version was release in 1960 (an adapted version having only been released until then). Today, the book’s message of following natural instincts despite society’s expectations is widely accepted, and the novel has been adapted into film many times.

 The turn in general opinion surrounding this book shows just how complicated the debate can be as culture, opinion, beliefs, and the acceptance of these views, change overtime. The reaction of the public when this book was published perhaps only shows how impactful the message of the author was as it challenged a long-held view on an important pillar of society. If the book industry refuses to print such books, or alters the content to fit in with society’s opinions, messages and useful insights into the nature of such reactions like these, will potentially be lost.

More recently, in the USA more and more books have been banned by right-wing groups. These books often deal with themes such as LGBTQ+, anti-church, politics and sex education. Spiegelman’s Maus, a graphic novel about the Holocaust, was banned for its use of explicit language. A novel with the intended purpose of educating young children on the atrocities of the Holocaust, as to spread awareness and keep alive the memory of the victims, deals with much harder content and more intricate problems than swearing. Arguably, this is a controversial book that, if anyone should find inappropriate to be read by younger children, should not be rejected on the basis of its use of foul language.

Another example of a more modern book would be the children’s beloved series, Harry Potter, which has also been banned in certain religious communities for its magical theme. This series is now controversial again for other reasons. Namely, the author’s own views, whether expressed in the book or not. This brings around many more questions; should you not read a book because of controversy surrounding its author, or are created and creator separable and able to be appreciated within their own rights? Books bring out different emotions and opinions in everyone, largely based on the reader’s own views. Sometimes these will be influenced by the author’s views but other times, people keep them separate. Therefore, we must find a balance and be careful to protect freedom of speech as well as access to literature whilst ensuring that potential harm caused by the author is acknowledged.

Should you not read a book because of controversy surrounding its author, or are created and creator separable and able to be appreciated within their own rights?

But what about books that pose a real danger in the contents of their thoughts and messages? Take Adolf Hitler’s book Mein Kampf, for example. Until 2016, this book was banned, and the State of Bavaria held the copyright alone. The first printed edition after this was heavily annotated and came with a lengthy introduction as a precaution. Whilst in Britain this book and other Nazi literature are not banned, in Germany there are still diverse opinions over whether it should be read at all. This is understandable given Germany’s attempts to stamp out Nazism and its surrounding ideological debates, but should there also be more care in Great Britain over this? The balance between treating Mein Kampf as a significantly important historical source and a political autobiography full of dangerous ideology is very complicated. Where does protection become censorship and the right to information become dangerous? Perhaps the idea of publishing with annotations and warnings is the best compromise as the book industry struggles to find this balance.

The recent scandals surrounding rewriting Roald Dahl and other authors’ works seems to have proved to cause more issues surrounding keeping the integrity of books, whether controversial or not. Perhaps Disney’s approach of adding disclaimers and explanations to the beginning of their films containing outdated or offensive themes is the best route to take. This would confirm what we have seen before with books like Mein Kampf, as it acknowledges issues without changing the integrity of the original work and leaves room for debate and further research into the problems. This also means that future generations can learn from the outdated messages, why they were there in the first place and how important it was to move past them and view them as educational means rather than squashing the problem and acting like it didn’t exist, which is dangerous in its own right. That road would likely only lead to similar behaviours and views repeating themselves on top of loss of material integrity and censorship. Therefore, it seems sensible to say that this method of addressing the issue is one of the best options for the book industry right now. This doesn’t mean, however, that any book which people take offense to should be treated this way – as if that was the case, almost every book would have to be introduced and annotated in such fashion. Instead, this is best left for those causing the book industry real issues. It should not become a commonplace thing. This would only take away the importance of it when it actually needs to be used.

Future generations can learn from the outdated messages, why they were there in the first place and how important it was to move past them and view them as educational means rather than squashing the problem and acting like it didn’t exist, which is dangerous in its own right

In conclusion, controversial books are important to keep in circulation and debate, if not to always be accepted. Every book will have its own impact on an individual and each individual will take something slightly different away from it as life experiences, beliefs, opinions and intended messages amalgamate and form new thoughts and questions in readers’ heads. A book that is controversial now, to a particular person or group of people, might not be in the future, or to somebody else. This does not mean that the book is not worth reading but, in fact, that it may be more worthy of reading. These controversial books often show important insights into history and teach valuable lessons with their messages which demonstrate that people and society change.

These controversial books often show important insights into history and teach valuable lessons with their messages which demonstrate that people and society change

Whilst the messages and ideology of some books do pose social and cultural dangers, the complete banning of them is perhaps not the right answer. Instead, warnings, annotations (not rewrites or censors) and acknowledgements of the content of such books would most likely serve well in upholding the integrity of the literature, freedom of speech and historical use whilst ensuring that people do not take onboard harmful ideologies whilst reading them and that as many people as possible are placated. In the future, as more voices join the debate around whether we should read controversial books, it is likely that more solutions will come up. These may prove fruitless or they may prove effective, but, either way, people around the world will go on reading controversial books and gaining insightful knowledge and different perspectives to further add to the debate. We can only hope that in a rapidly advancing world, accessibility to literature continues in the least harmful way possible.

Image credit: Jane Mount via Reclamation magazine