Outdated degree classifications ‘must change’
THE CURRENT SYSTEM of degree classification has come under yet more criticism as vice-chancellors across the UK labelled the system outdated.
The two hundred year old classification system gives too little information to employers, they told the Commons’ Universities Select Committee at the end of January. As the UK economy becomes ever more reliant on knowledge-based activities, arguments for a more detailed breakdown of results have become more pertinent as employers search for the best candidates for jobs.
Currently, universities are largely responsible for setting their own standards, and are only reviewed by the Quality Assurance Agency for Higher Education to ensure that they are maintaining those standards. The lack of a ‘national curriculum’ means that, according to Phil Williams, Chair of the select committee, “there’s no consistency between subjects or institutions”.
Rick Trainor, President of Universities UK, alluded to this when he told the select committee that “A first in ancient history from [one] university is not the same as a first in tourism and management from [another] university”, but added “both fully uphold standards that fulfil the purposes of their courses.”
The debate over the classification of degrees is not a new one. Already, a small group of higher education institutions are trialling Higher Education Achievement Reports (HEAR), a recommendation of a report by the “Burgess Group” produced in 2007.
The Higher Education Achievement Reports were endorsed by those speaking to the select committee.
