Out of our depth

Reviewing music is inherently cursed by the fact that you only review what you love. Indigo took six genre aficionados and threw them into the deep end of a completely contrasting style. What ensued was not pretty at all…

 

FOLK AND INDIE

Reviewers: Wilf Odgers & Tom Moore

Job title: Student promoters of Body Language club night

Music taste: Drum and bass, house, dubstep

Tracks reviewed: ‘Falling Wood’ by Joseph & David (Folk)

‘You Like White Women, I Like Cigarettes’ by Howler (Indie)

 

‘Joseph & David’ – the most imaginatively named band since the debut single of Anaal Nathrakh – offer up this next iteration in the ever-increasingly bland sub-genre of folk commonly known as ‘The O.C. Breakup-or-Death Background Music’. ‘Falling Wood’ slots nicely in to place along with eternal greats such as Damien Jurado – ‘What Were the Chances’ and Trent Dabbs – ‘True Love Goes’. The gentle cooing of Joseph and/or David gently coaxes the listener inside a comforting blanket of audible delight, lulling them into a false sense of security before asphyxiating them with the plastic bag of indifference. This is a song that is designed to illicit emotions (presumably about ongoing deforestation… we’re not sure) for those who ‘like to talk about their feelings’. For all our criticism, one line in particular did resonate with us: “Falling wood / Don’t you know that time will save us?” – we only wish that we could save the time that we lost on this song.

 

Whisky and painkillers. Two words that spring to mind when faced with a life filled only of the back catalogue of Minneapolis band Howler, proponents of Nu-Post-Apocalypse-Rock – a world where Distorted Guitar Strumming is king, attended to by his unerring mistress, Post-Relationship Angst. Back in our politically correct reality, the title ‘You Like White Women, I Like Cigarettes’ treads a fine line between absurdity and moral abhorrence. Perhaps they should adopt the alternative, more considerate offering: ‘You Like All People Regardless Of Their Sexual Orientation, Gender or Racial Background, I Like Cigarettes (Although I Recognise That They Are Detrimental To My Health and That Smoking Makes Me A Bad Role Model To Younger Generations)’. Musically, this track offers little in the way of originality, but that’s to be expected from a genre famous for being utterly devoid of new ideas. That NME determined Howler the third best new band of 2011 is a sure a sign as any that an inevitable decline into (more) obscurity awaits. Goodbye Howler.

 

CHART

Reviewer: Joe Ennis

Job title: Devout metalhead

Music taste: All types of metal

Track reviewed: ‘Stupid Hoe’ by Nicki Minaj

No melody, repetitive drumming and lyrics that make less sense than a physics textbook written entirely in Sanskrit. As initial impressions go these aren’t good ones and unfortunately repeated listening doesn’t do much to change them. From the title alone you can tell that Nicki is angry at someone (a cursory Google suggests Lil’ Kim) and if I was going to review this purely as a diss track then I could probably say a few nice things, it certainly gets its point across (she really doesn’t like Lil’ Kim) and some of the insults are bordering on clever. But, as a song, it falls far short of the mark. The lack of any backing beyond the incredibly repetitive drum track means that the song really does rest on its lyrics and they just aren’t good enough, rhymes rely far too much on Nicki’s rather… interesting… pronunciation. There’s some potential here but it would be better for her to leave off the bitching till she make a decent song whilst doing it.

 

CLASSICAL

Reviewer: Tim Hurst

Job title: Vice President of Full Collapse, Durham’s longest running alternative music event

Music taste: Heavy and alternative rock

Track reviewed: ‘Jupiter’ by Holst

This piece is full of energy from the start. The orchestra builds tension wonderfully throughout the first minute before switching to a much more lighthearted melody. The piece changes smoothly between contrasting emotions and conveys them perfectly. I particularly enjoy the shift in focus of different sections of the orchestra to help convey the different moods of the song, such as the light jumpy xylophones, emphasized during the happier sections, being swapped for bowed violins as the track gets moodier. I don’t often listen to orchestral music but I have really warmed to this piece due to its use of dynamics and timbre.  I am a fan of the percussion in this performance; often this can be a factor which turns me off classical music.

 

ELECTRONICA

Reviewer: Octavia Lewis

Job title: Publicity Officer for Musicon, Durham University’s professional classical concert series

Music tastes: Classical, jazz, big band

Track reviewed: ‘Raise Your Weapon (Noisia Remix)’ by Deadmau5

How on earth to start? Analysing a piece, to me means stirring up the tiniest dregs of enthusiasm for a piece’s ‘rich harmonic language’ somewhere around 3am, when confusion about what on earth to write about gives way to the helpful lucidity of sheer panic. ‘Rich harmonic language’ here wouldn’t get anywhere. Perhaps this is what Darth Vader could have sounded like if he took to electronica. The remixing is the most impressive. It’s clean and tells a whole new story while overlays of the original sound throughout remind of the opening, but never gain a foothold. Could the conclusion ever have been predicted? Somewhere near the beginning there was a hardly perceptible change from piano to electronics; then modification took over; tonality was bent; and the beat became all encompassing. If I had to relate it to a more classical form, it could, perhaps, function as a theme and variations? Perhaps. It’s the little things that make me happy, and I really like this, from the details of the mixing to the robot with the Top Gun-esque sunglasses on the YouTube recording. But talking of great music, Musicon’s Festival of East Asian Music anyone?

 

METAL

Reviewer: Rob Symmons

Job title: Organiser of Vane Tempest Sessions, Durham’s intimate folk and indie gig promotion company

Music taste: Folk, indie, alternative

Track reviewer: ‘Ghostwalking’ by Lamb of God

Whilst I pride myself on having a relatively broad taste in music, I have rarely strayed much ‘heavier’ than Pulled Apart By Horses, and I went into the Lamb of God track with little hope. However, there was a lot in the track that appealed to me. The driving guitars, furious drumming and insanely impassioned performance all round made me certain it would make for an amazing live experience. Even the much maligned strained vocals didn’t put me off too much-obviously I prefer the silky tones of Laura Marling, but with a backing track like that, I’m not sure even she could pull it off. However the one barrier for me were the lyrics. The ideal song for me would be just as effective as a poem, where the wordplay grips you completely. ‘Ghost Walker’ reminds me of the teenage angst poetry I wrote at the age of 15 upon being dumped. Randy Blythe is 40 now. Surely he’s moved on in the past 25 years?