Oscars’ new diversity rules
By Megan Cooper
The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences has recently announced new rules surrounding their awards, or as we know them, the Oscars. Coming into effect in 2024, the new rules concern only the Best Picture category, and ensure a film can only get a coveted nomination if it fulfils the criteria in two out of four categories. Two of the categories are aimed at diversity within the nominated film’s production company or distributor through training opportunities or within senior positions. The remaining two concern the cast and crew of the film itself. (Full details can be found
here: https://www.oscars.org/news/academy-establishes-representation-and-inclusion-standards-oscarsr-eligibility)
After recent criticism around the Oscars ceremonies, including #OscarsSoWhite in 2015, these measures come as a way to include more representation of minority racial or ethnic groups, and a wider range of identities. That the Academy has recognised the issues within the industry – and its place in upholding and reinforcing these issues – and has taken action is surely a positive sign.
Permanently expanding the Best Picture category to 10 nominees, as well as appointing a new cohort of voting members including Lakeith Stanfield, Lulu Wang, Park So-dam, Zendaya and Cynthia Erivo also shows how the Academy is moving (very slowly) in the right direction, with 45% of these
new appointees being women, and 36% people of colour.
These rules however arguably offer no nuance and very little real terms change; if they had been implemented for the 2019 ceremony for example, a film like Green Book would still have been nominated, and would still have won against films like Blackkklansman and Black Panther. Fantastic
films that instinctively fulfil this criteria, and not as an afterthought – Dolemite Is My Name, Us, The Farewell, Booksmart and Hustlers to name a few – are also already being completely overlooked in the ceremonies.
Fulfilling quotas speaks nothing to how people are represented.
It does nothing to tackle the Oscars’ obsession with awarding Black talent when it is presented in a slave narrative or white saviour story; the only non-white nominee in the Best Actress category in 2020 was for Cynthia Erivo for her
portrayal of Harriet Tubman. And Halle Berry is still the only Black woman to have ever won the award. It also does nothing when a film like Bohemian Rhapsody can get nominated for best picture, a biopic of one of the most famous queer men, despite this very portrayal of the ‘criteria fulfilling’ aspect of his life being widely criticised. And as recent Netflix documentary Disclosure details, trans representation on screen has a long history of being harmful.
There is no doubt the temptation of a shiny gold statue still has sway over the industry, with the release schedules of films still largely dictated by the ceremony itself being held in February, but these measures are a top down minimal solution to a problem that can only really be tackled at the
grass roots.
Indie films have always been doing these things as a given, have always been telling diverse stories by a diverse group of people.
The rules concerning training opportunities are promising, but it’s about the people in power having a genuine desire to tell these stories, and taking risks on talent, not just as an afterthought to bagging a star-studded film a Best Picture nomination.
Showbusiness after all is a business, and people want to know they’re going to make money. So should we as an audience demand more from the stories we’re being shown, and do it by putting our money where our mouths are?
Concerns about this affecting certain genres (war) are also misguided, with films like 1917 still perfectly able to pass the criteria for diversity behind the camera and within the production company. A film like Little Women can also pass with flying colours, with women being counted as a minority group. There is very little then to actually encourage radical ideas and sets when the rules can be reduced to a box ticking exercise, and the existing hierarchies of discrimination being reinforced.
There has been a sea change in the industry though, and big names are continuing to use their platform to the benefit of those who don’t share it. Recent Best Picture winners Parasite, The Favourite and Moonlight are incredibly exciting and hopeful harbingers, and one can only hope that
by starting with the most anticipated award, other categories that are woefully lacking in diversity like Best Director and Best Actress will follow.
Image: mohamed Hassan from Pixabay
