Osborne’s cutting axe takes its first substantial swing

Like a medieval axe man inspecting his tools before the final execution, the government has been softening up voters ahead of the spending review for weeks now. So when George Osborne finally brought his financial axe crashing down on the bulging budget deficit, it was strange that a whiff of anticlimax fumigated from the smoldering remains.

A Tory minister recently said that ‘the headlines could have been a lot worse’. It seems as if, as well as crossing bipartisan lines the coalition derives a strange satisfaction from being derided from all sides. Their theory goes that if everyone is painfully bleating that the cuts are unfair, they are ironically broadly fair for everybody.

Up and down Whitehall, the Lib-Con pact is patting itself on the back. The biggest challenge of their premiership so far has passed without any major hiccoughs. Given that they have just imported an unprecedented £81bn worth of public spending cuts, this is no mean feat. Labour’s criticisms have, thus far, fallen on deaf ears. The new shadow chancellor, Alan Johnson, took the direct route of accusing the Coalition of selecting the cuts along ideological lines. This approach has been derided by many due to Labour’s current economic credibility.

Ed Miliband recently proclaimed with all his political zest that ‘this was a spending cut driven by ideology’.  According to Labour, there are plenty of backbench Tories who see the shrinking of the state as an ideological goal. The Opposition still portray the Clegg-Cameron couple as an ideological union primarily interested in preserving the interests of a privileged elite, rather than the national interest.

The number of public sector job losses (490,000) is enough to make any voter think twice about voting for the Conservatives or the Lib Dems again. However, the real reason that commentators are skeptical about the Coalition’s cuts can be found elsewhere. The first is a simple practicality: these cuts are just plans. The Coalition are yet to encounter the infinite joys of implementation. It is also rumored that many cabinet ministers have not fully appreciated the dwindling funds of their budgets. Many may find that typing hollow figures into a spreadsheet is very different to actually sacking staff and cutting off services.

Assuming that the Coalition can ensure that their sharpened cutting axe falls down without any hash jobs, they must still convince the public that they can replace the jobs that they are systematically extricating from the economy.

The Coalition feel that if they can cure the pain that they are currently doling out, voters will forgive them. However, they need to ensure that these cuts will definitely lead to a sustainable recovery. The only way for this to happen is if the private sector expands as fast as the state shrinks. Unfortunately, commentators assure us that this eventuality relies on an unconsummated boom in the economy over the coming years. Mr. Osborne has made bold assumptions about the private sector’s capacity for rapid growth. The Coalition is radical to its core. Whether they are too radical economically remains to be seen.

Comments are closed.