Orange is the New Black (is the new black)
There are several mechanisms for preferentially representing one group over another in television. These can be explicitly stated or structurally implied. Through time, western culture has progressed away from the former and towards the latter.
The privileged group in our media is very typically men/white men/rich white men. Mainly due to our institutionalization as an audience it can be easy to miss or forget certain biases implicit in television content. It is in this regard that we should consider the value of Jenji Kohan’s Orange is the New Black (OITNB), which provides an illuminating counterpoint to many of the more subtle structural biases in mainstream television.
Through the creation of a prison world, dominated by the social dynamics of mostly poor women of a variety of ethnicities, OITNB shows us something that would appear shocking to someone whose understanding of the world was solely informed by television. It is not just white men who enjoy a rich social tapestry embedded with obscene jokes, sexual repartee, mendacity and complex struggles for power and happiness.
Who would have known how rich ‘lesbian banter’ is before listening to the dialogue of characters such as Carrie “Big Boo” Black and Nicky Nichols? For every obscenity men deliver to each other about how much they would like to do this or that sexual act with/to a women, it turns out that there’s a whole world of corresponding (and, typically, much better and more vulgar) female sexual badinage.
This implicit imposition in mainstream television, that men enjoy some monopoly over obscenity and the more complex social interactions, is the prevailing subconscious attitude among men. In an age of liberal tolerance, clinging to this monopoly is a way in which the ruling male social class establish superiority, while still feeling progressive in accepting the formal requirements and implied values of multicultural discourse.
OITNB challenges its audience to fully assimilate and empathize with the backstories of members of obviously ostracized groups, such as transgender Sophia Burset and the mentally unstable adoptee Suzanne “Crazy Eyes” Warren. Importantly, the show goes further.
For example, the religious fanatic and rape victim, Tiffany “Pennsatucky” Doggett, and her Amish contemporary, Leanne Taylor, do not so easily demand the viewer’s sympathy or identify as victims. This seems both to be because of their own intolerance of characters such as Sophia, as well as because they don’t fall into our typical categories of a member of an oppressed group. However, as the audience gets to know these characters, it’s easy to empathize and see their tragedies.
In the third season, the viewer follows the moving struggle for identity and acceptance of the bawdry and brazen “Big Boo”, who is seldom a figure to inspire affection throughout the rest of the show. Again, “Big Boo” represents a more problematic character for the liberal viewer. There is something revealing in her surprisingly poignant backstory.
There have certainly been sensitive depictions of lesbian characters in television and film (Blue is the Warmest Colour comes to mind) but none with a protagonist such as “Big Boo”. My claim in all three (Tiffany, Leanne and “Big Boo”) is that depictions of passive representatives for a marginalised group fit into our simplistic public discussion of tolerance and multiculturalism, whereas individuals who don’t accept their role as victim and/or are bold and unapologetic representatives of their marginalised groups, do not.
OITNB goes further through the character of George Mendez. As the quintessentially misogynistic and sadistic prison guard, he personifies a certain bête noire for any viewer sensitive to gender issues and prejudice. Mendez represents the most threatening “Other” within contemporary liberal worldviews of compassion and inclusivity. Mendez cannot be assimilated into any dominant egalitarian vision because, by nature, he threatens that very vision. Tolerating him is intolerable for the tolerant. OITNB questions this and encourages our empathy for Mendez as we watch his tragedy unfold after being set-up and imprisoned for the rape of an inmate.
A further theme in the show is power; in the relationships between inmates but, more interestingly, in the prison’s power structure itself. In this regard, the first two seasons critique the publicly owned system, particularly in the character of corrupted assistant warden Natalie “Fig” Figueroa (accurately parodied as a pig carrying money by the inmates in an Animal Farm-style cartoon). Fig’s contempt for the prisoners is striking, as is her role in propping up an ultimately patriarchal institution of oppression. Both cases imply a wider critique of contemporary society.
Perhaps the most obvious institutional critique is exhibited in how easily and blithely the powerful (the warden and assistant warden) can make a decision in their own interest, which causes enormous suffering among the inmates and often to the other prison workers. This dynamic is revealed to be worse after the prison moves into private ownership. The inmates ultimately become commodities and pawns in the money-making games of the bureaucratic company owners.
More disrespect for orthodoxy is revealed in Piper Chapman’s status as protagonist. It almost seems as though the show is toying with its viewers by having Piper as a somewhat orthodox protagonist throughout the first series. The audience would even be forgiven for envisioning a happy ending in which Piper finally marries Larry. As the second series comes though, Piper’s story fizzles out, as does her status as the moral heart of the show. From there, the viewer is left with the morally ambiguous world of the inmate’s ambivalent backstories and the intricate prison world they inhabit.
OITNB has proven itself to be both surprising and subversive, making the wait for a fourth season particularly agonising.
Image: Netflix/Lionsgate Television/Tilted Productions and Jordan Jacobs via Wikimedia Commons

