One Night Only – Started A Fire

REVIEWERS ACROSS ALL the arts are often criticised for linguistic self-indulgence. They seem to revel in obscuring relatively simplistic sentiments and ideas with unnecessarily convoluted wordplay (see?). A negative opinion invariably becomes a diatribe, a positive one a hyperbolic love-in. Of course, this is because expressing strong feelings using clever words is easy – there are so many to choose from that it would seem churlish not to cram at least eighteen of them into every sentence. The real difficulty lies in describing indifference with a comparable level of excess. How does one set about articulately describing something as “very average”?

You do it like this: a very average band, One Night Only, have recorded a very average album, Started a Fire. The North Yorkshire quintet actually played a supporting slot to The Pigeon Detectives at Durham venue Studio fairly recently (November 2007), whereupon having witnessed their performance fellow Palatinate hack Eve da Silva remarked “…their energy and sound make up for the generic feel of some of their music” in a subsequent review.

Judging by the sound of their debut fell-length, she was right on the money. Ernest delivery is certainly there in abundance, along with a smattering of memorable hooks on tracks like single You and Me (think The Longcut) and opener Just for Tonight. Originality, though, is in desperately short supply.

Granted, in some ways One Night Only are in fact something of a unique proposition – lead singer George Craig is a remarkable 17 years old, while despite their youth the band have been around for almost five years. Started a Fire certainly isn’t a “bad” record either, particularly if you happen to be a fan of Supergrass (see It’s Alright), Manic Street Preachers (ditto Start Over) or any number of the interchangeable indie outfits spawned this decade.

The rhythm section is as taut as any this side of The Futureheads, Craig’s impressive range lends itself well to his soaring vocals and suitably jangly guitar lines decorate the album throughout. There’s even a hint of experimentation on Sweet Sugar with the incorporation of a trumpet, believe it or not.

Started a Fire is undeniably an enjoyable listen. It couldn’t be anything else – its songs are radio fodder of the kind that one couldn’t possibly object to, already having been playlisted at over 70 stations nationwide. With any luck One Night Only will build on this to accomplish a more substantial sophomore outing, perhaps better striking the balance between pop sensibility and instrumental creativity. In the mean time we’re left with this, a set of songs at once both comfortingly familiar and yet disappointingly disposable.

Very average indeed.