Once More, There and Back Again: The Hobbit
Seventy-five years ago, an Oxford Professor of Anglo-Saxon literature published a book which he began, in a flash of inspiration, on a blank exam paper, with the now immortal opening line: ‘In a hole in the ground there lived a hobbit.’ That hobbit, Bilbo Baggins, as portrayed by Martin Freeman, arrived in December 2012 on the silver screen in the first part of a new trilogy from New Line Cinema, a decade after the theatrical release of the novel’s successor The Lord of the Rings. But what is it about the book that makes it so popular?
On a basic level, Tolkien’s novel is a straightforward adventure story. Bilbo leaves his comfortable home in the company of thirteen dwarves, all set on a journey to retrieve lost treasure – which happens to be guarded by a particularly dangerous dragon. The narrative is lively and accessible; nearly all the characters are memorable and unique in their own ways; the background is richly realised and tangible and the denouement is satisfying.
Is that all there is to it? No. There are subtle yet powerful undercurrents flowing throughout the novel which become lodged in the subconscious through a first reading in childhood, but come to the fore when reviewing the novel with an adult’s eyes.
Take the hero, Bilbo. To many readers, he is a comic character. Indolent, timid almost to the point of cowardice, he is a bewildering choice of companion from the dwarves’ point of view: ‘He looks more like a grocer than a burglar!’ His mishaps early on in his adventures are humorous and exasperating, as Tolkien shows through Bilbo’s clumsy attempt to rob the troll trio, an escapade which nearly results in him and the dwarves being cooked!
Yet it is these aspects of his personality which make him a lovably protagonist, because he is so (for want of a better description) human in his behaviour. Children and adults alike identify with his fear of the unknown and admire his commonsense approach to life. More importantly, Bilbo changes throughout the tale as he uncovers emotional strengths he did not know he possessed. After all, not many people could hold their nerve in a tense riddle game against a creature who wants to eat you! Later on in the story, his verbal battle with Smaug is outstanding since Tolkien uses this encounter to demonstrate how far Bilbo’s personal courage and initiative has developed from his earlier bumbling efforts with the trolls. For these reasons, Bilbo remains an enduring, and endearing, heroic individual.
It is not only Bilbo’s journey though. Tolkien provides a cast of dwarves as Bilbo’s companions, and out of the thirteen Thorin, leader of the group and heir to the treasure stolen by Smaug, is the most complex and interesting character. In many ways Thorin is the antithesis of Bilbo; well acquainted with suffering and hardship and toughened by life’s events, he is an important figure within his own circle.
However, Thorin’s journey can be seen as Tolkien’s version of a cautionary tale. Thorin is brave and loyal to his companions, but he is also proud and overly susceptible to the lure of his ancestors’ treasure. It is this fatal combination of flaws which proves Thorin’s undoing, and his final fate offers a warning to readers of the chaos which can erupt from uncontrolled avarice – a warning which, given the current economic situation, is perhaps especially resonant with readers today.
Tolkien offers other messages throughout the novel, though he never becomes didactic. His distaste for greed and gain is balanced by his obvious love for nature’s beauty, from ‘the fair valley of Rivendell’ as Elrond’s precious haven to Beorn’s homestead with its beehives and his animal companions. Tolkien saves his anger for the goblins, ‘cruel, wicked, and bad-hearted,’ who delight in creating ‘instruments of torture’ and causing wanton destruction.
Yet Tolkien also offers a plea for tolerance and understanding between the ‘good’ characters. Dwarves and elves are continually at odds, humans do not trust either race, and while the eagles are allies to all three, they ‘are not kindly’ and ‘proud.’ The petty differences between the races culminate in the confrontation at the end of the novel, when elves and men march on the dwarves for the sake of the gold, and are only prevented from fighting each other by the entrance of a mutual enemy. Thus Tolkien argues for people to find common ground, despite their quarrels, in order to protect what is personally and universally valuable within their world.
While there are these reasons and more for The Hobbit’s popularity, ultimately each reader finds their own cause for taking this novel to their heart. So go on. Pick it up again. Reacquaint yourself with Bilbo, Gandalf, Gollum, Smaug and Middle-Earth. Go on your own journey – there and back again.
Photograph: Samuel Spencer

