NUS President calls for rethink of “ill-considered” fees
NUS President, Aaron Porter, called on the Government to rethink “ill-considered” tuition fee plans as the deadline approaches for universities wanting to charge above £6000 to declare how they will help disadvantaged students.
Universities’ plans, which include means-tested bursaries and fee waivers, must be submitted to the Office for Fair Access (Offa) for 2012 by the end of today.
Tuition fees will be finalised in July when Offa confirms the fees it has approved for each university.
But Mr Porter questions Offa’s power to stop universities charging the maximum fees: “Ministers have claimed that Offa has the power to regulate fees, when in reality this process is nothing more than one of rubber stamping vice chancellors’ attempts to charge as much as they can get away with. With no one to stop them, universities are rushing to charge the maximum £9,000.”
And so far almost 70 higher education institutions have announced their proposed fees for 2012. Three-quarters of these intend to charge the maximum £9000.
The Guardian calculated that the average tuition fee amongst universities who have stated their prices for 2012 is £8,678.36.
Mr Porter criticised the increased tuition fees that will come into force for students starting university in 2012: “when the government forced these ill-considered plans through parliament they claimed that fees above £6,000 would be the exception rather than rule, but that was quite clearly a pipe dream.
“Government ministers must take responsibility for the costly chaos they have created and take the entire scheme back to the drawing board before it causes irreparable damage to universities.”
But Universities Minister, David Willets, argued that the increase in fees will benefit students: “we should never forget the importance of competition by quality. Many parents and students will be worried about how many seminars they will get, what arrangements there are for work experience and how much coursework will be set.
“Universities will be publishing more data than ever before so that parents and students can compare performance and choose where to apply for accordingly. The money will go with the choices the student makes.
And Willets also commented that prospective applicants for 2012/13 could find “hidden extras”. “Many [students] actually face the likelihood of hidden discounts because of the way in which universities have gone about publicising their fee plans.
“The reality is that lots of students will not face fees anything close to £9,000 a year – including at the most prestigious universities.”
But recently-elected NUS President for 2011/12, Liam Burns, criticised the “idiotic system” which he believes is “in chaos”.
“The system now being put into place by the coalition government […] doesn’t go as far as I suspect many of its members would have hoped.
He continued: “NUS made it clear that the Government’s system would result in most universities opting to charge £9,000 tuition fees. The Office for Budget Responsibility and the Institute for Fiscal Studies provide evidence that it would cost the taxpayer more as well as loading graduates with debt, while independent studies show that when presented with the prospect of upwards of £40,000 of debt many would decide not to take the risk.
“Still the government ploughed ahead with this idiotic system and thousands upon thousands of young people will suffer as a result”.
A White Paper setting out how higher education will be reformed in England is expected this summer.

