No place like home: Durham University under fire for lack of student housing

By Jack Newbury

Exacerbated by the cost of living crisis, the housing market squeeze is being felt like never before. In Durham, ambitious plans for University expansion seem incompatible with a small city already under significant strain. The Durham student population was 6,500 in the 1990/91 academic year, swelling to 15,500 by 2013/14 and 20,000 in 2020/21. As the University headcount grows, a very basic supply and demand issue befalls Durham. How does a limited stock of housing continue to satisfy this consistent recent growth in the student population? The answer seems to be increased rent costs. The competition for the same number of houses can only get worse if the University grows its ranks.

Demand and supply

Residents and students alike are bearing the brunt of current price increases. Locals, perhaps justifiably, see students as the root cause of rent inflation. Students did not come to Durham with the intention of saturating the housing market. Indeed, many locals now face the heartbreaking decision to leave their hometown as they get priced out. The deep-rooted supply issue means students can do nothing but accept well-above-inflation rent costs. A typical house on Elvet Crescent faces a 20% rent hike from £149 per person per week to £179, all without bills included.

What next?

Since student numbers are the driving force behind the market failure, Durham University’s admissions policy is facing increased scrutiny. Indeed, the ‘Durham University Strategy 2017-2027’ gives an insight into the future direction of the housing market.

The University has laid out the following goals to be reached by 2027: first, an increase to 21,500 students. There is also an aim to integrate four to six new colleges, twinned with a goal to have 50% of students living in college. The fourth and final goal is to have 35% of the student body comprising international students.

Since student numbers are the driving force behind the market failure, Durham University’s admissions policy is facing increased scrutiny

The role of college accommodation

Upon closer inspection, the University’s goal to house half of all students in colleges shows that the University Council is aware of the ongoing housing problem. In current market conditions, only 35% of students are living in University accommodations. A 15% reduction in demand for private renting would go a long way to ease supply issues and force down prices. To achieve this goal, the University has laid out proposals for ‘four to six’ new colleges by 2027. If the University achieved these goals the housing market in Durham would undoubtedly be significantly eased. However, the other figures present a more worrying picture.

The 21,500-student target simply seems unfeasible. The City of Durham Trust reported that the University’s provisional figures listed 22,200 students in the last academic year. The last available data from the University (2020/21) recorded 20,000 students, a 900-student increase from the year before.

In fact, over the last five years, the average yearly growth in the University has been 468 students. If we accept the Durham Trust’s figure of 22,200 students in the 2021/22 year and apply the average yearly growth of the last five years until the 2026/27 strategy expires, we find that the University will be home to 24,540 students – in other words – an overshoot of 3,040 heads. If there were a significant overshoot in numbers the ‘four to six’ new colleges would pick up that overpopulation strain and would thus be largely unable to increase the percentage of total students living in colleges. However, the University says that it has reduced its intake for the 2022/23 year and intends to do so again for 2023/24.

The international effect

The University seems keen to expand its proportion of international students, sitting at 25% in the 2020/21 year. The 2026/27 goal is 35%. .The University make a point of ‘Global Durham’ with the official line of aiming to “be a globally networked university.”
Cynics would note that perhaps being able to charge international students around 250% the fees of home students (around £21,730 to £27,350) is the driver behind this ‘Global Durham’ goal.

A cynic’s take

Further, students who are cynical of the University’s motives have argued that the overshoot in student numbers, far from an accident, is the aim of the University. Certainly, it is hard to believe the University leadership could blindly blunder into this statistical dilemma. Instead, it might be argued that the goal of the University, far from alleviating stress on the renting market, is to cultivate a student population with enough money to pay whatever rent costs might be incurred as a result of Durham’s expansion aims. That level of cynicism may be unfair to the University, though one thing is clear: if the Durham housing market is going to get any better, the University needs to carefully consider the consequences of its housing plans. After all, students need to have somewhere to live.

Image: Durham University via Wikimedia Commons. Author: Bill Henderson