No Exit: can you escape the gaze of ‘the Others’?

By Ha Trang Pham


“So this is hell. I’d never have believed it. You remember all we were told about the torture-chambers, the fire and brimstone, the “burning marl.” […] 

Hell is—other people!”


“L’enfer, c’est les Autres”, goes the chilling quote from Jean-Paul Sartre’s 1944 French philosophical play No Exit (Huis Clos). And indeed, on my view hell is other people! While I mean it in a relatable, introverted sense, I aim to discuss the meaning of this declaration according to Sartre’s own existentialist philosophy and how it embodies the tragedy of the human condition. 

No Exit follows Garcin, Inez and Estelle, three individuals who have died in different ways and are now trapped in Hell. Except this isn’t your typical depiction of Hell; instead, it is a simple drawing room with ordinary furniture: no window, no mirror, no eyelids (they cannot close their eyes!) and no torture devices or executioner to punish them. So what makes this place Hell?

Hell is other people

After many conflicts and much reflection on their past lives, the three characters finally come to the shocking realisation that they are none other than each other’s torturers. They are to inflict psychological pain and agony on each other, forever – that is the punishment that awaits them in Hell. Hell is other people. 

Human beings are inherently social creatures; we cling onto what others think of us and constantly seek external validation. This allows others to make choices for us and convince us that we have no control over our lives. Sartre calls this the power of ‘the Others’. This is portrayed in the play through the absence of windows and mirrors, and the inability to close our eyes. You have no way of looking at your reflection, making your own judgement or denying the oppressive presence of ‘the Others’. Your existence relies entirely on the gaze of those around you. That is Hell, as conceived in the play. 


“Estelle: You scare me rather. My reflection in the glass never did that; of course, I knew it so well. Like something I had tamed… I’m going to smile, and my smile will sink down into your pupils, and heaven knows what it will become.”


‘The Others’ distort and alter sense of self, interfering with one’s ability to conceive of oneself in a particular way. The character of Inez understands and epitomises the power of the Others’ gaze. She’s ruthless, blunt and cunning, manipulating Estelle and Garcin’s perceptions of themselves and of each other throughout the play. 

Your existence relies entirely on the gaze of those around you. That is Hell, as conceived in the play

The vain Estelle, obsessed with feminine appearance, is afraid of Inez’s gaze. Unlike in a mirror where she can confirm her own sense of self, she has no control over how Inez perceives her, which throws her into an existential crisis. She also desperately tries to get with Garcin as she always thirsts for male validation: she defines her worth and essence by attaching herself to a man, submitting to his gaze.

Meanwhile, Garcin initially evades Inez for consistently scrutinising him, while Estelle tells him what he wants to hear. But gradually, he becomes fixated on Inez’s accusations because she does not hesitate to tell him the brutal truth and sees through his cowardice. In the end, he believes he can only find salvation through Inez and cannot escape from Hell until he can change her perception of him. Garcin is so reliant on the Others’ perception of him that he is denying his freedom and agency to conceive of himself the way he wants. 


“Garcin: Will night never come?

Inez: Never.

Garcin: You will always see me?

Inez: Always.”


For both Estelle and Garcin, Hell is Inez, who torments and reigns over them like a judge in the courtroom.

Human interaction is torturous because it is from there that insecurities arise and all control is lost over perspective and identity. Yet, no matter what, there is still a strong and natural human urge to communicate and interact, thus continuing the vicious cycle of torture.

Sartre’s existentialism asserts that ‘existence precedes essence’; humans came into existence without any blueprint or pre-conceived essence that pre-determines how to live. With this overwhelming freedom comes responsibility – we are left to decide meaning and subsequent action. In Sartre’s own words: “we are left alone, without excuse” and “condemned to be free”. Once we use our freedom to make a choice, it is engraved into our essence forever. No Exit pushes this existentialist idea to its extremes where the characters have died and are condemned to be confronted and tortured by the consequences of their irreparable past actions. 


“Inez: One always dies too soon – or too late. And yet one’s whole life is complete at that moment, with a line drawn neatly under it, ready for the summing up. You are – your life, and nothing else.”


Sartre’s verdict is thus, think carefully, choose carefully, and use your freedom responsibly

Sartre’s verdict is thus, think carefully, choose carefully, and use your freedom responsibly. Don’t let ‘the Others’ crush you under their gaze and deny you your freedom and autonomy, because that would be denying your essence as a human being.

Image credit – Robin Finetto, Theo Chevallier