Nice news if you can get it

Self-awareness is something, I think, we all strive for. It seems to be the Holy Grail of that fun ride called growing up and something that fades in and out through much of life. So in the name of self awareness, I’ll state the obvious: the irony of my writing this piece is overwhelming. Student media, an enterprise into which I invest a lot of time, has served me pretty well so far. Bizarrely, then, I feel compelled to question the very nature of the pages on which these words are printed (nice, thick white pages though they are), partly because a self-aware paper is a better paper, but mostly because the News section is a pest and sharing is, after all, caring. Sorry, Palatinate, I love you really.

If we look to that great god of information, Wikipedia, student newspapers “traditionally cover local and, primarily, school or university news”. It’s in the name, stupid.  News is the anchor and the origin of the student papers- indeed, any paper- but, casting my eyes over the best of the country’s university press, the highlights are often found in the fresh, visually-slick features, opinion and arts sections.

News journalism in a university is a tricky business. All the presumed rules of practice and ethics of reporting are thrown into question in publishing information in such a small, dependent community. Here are the things we know: the media should report objectively, accurately and thoroughly; the media should hold the institutions and society around it accountable, and the media should inform – and sometimes entertain – its consumers. Here are the other things we know: student papers should report objectively, accurately and thoroughly; student papers should hold the institutions and society around them accountable, and student papers should inform – and often entertain – their consumers. It’s simple, right?

When I get bogged down in the production of Palatinate, I am reminded that it’s only a student paper. Like anyone feeling defeated by a problem, stepping back to see the bigger picture often does the trick in bringing  me back down to ground.

However, falling back on our student  status doesn’t always solve the problem, as being tied up with the academic community, both in terms of our production and our readership, brings with it both advantages and disadvantages. Yes, we’re the first to hear about the Easy Tiger campaign, and the like. The headline writes itself: ‘Easy, tiger! Students told alcohol is bad for health!’. Pulitzer on the way.

In spite of the advantages, and there are many, student newspapers can be held back by their very student status, since they are mostly neither sufficiently big nor independent to rely simply on the truth as jusitification for stories. There are a few notable exceptions, mostly obviously in Oxbridge, but even they must face the same dilemmas of what to print and what not to print with the welfare of various members of the university in mind.

At the end of the day, a student  paper should essentially be good for the attendents of said university. It becomes a joke if students start to do a unnecessary disservice to their fellow students in the name of media. So when a university paper discovers information about a student’s misdemenour, or a wrong-doing that would impact students, should they report it because it is wrong and the existence of news journalism rests upon a responsibilty to inform the public of the truth, or should they ignore it because highlighting it would injure the livelihood of the wrongdoer? It’s a Catch-22; ignore news and the function of student papers once again falls into question, flag it up and somebody’s mate gets screwed.

It is a scenario that can be played out with infinite variables. It comes down to which comes first – the student you are outside of the office or the hack you are inside? Perfect solutions on a postcard please.

No student newspaper seeks to injure their core, and indeed only, readership, but is there a place for student news if papers do not take the responsibilty of reporting the university’s events, even when not so rosy?

The solution is, I suspect, to make like a bad essay, and sit on the fence. Report when you have facts and can walk away with a clear conscience; don’t report when the reprecussions outweigh the comfort of sticking to your ethics. It can be a hard road to tread, and one not always well done.

My friends regularly remind me not to get myself blacklisted for the sake of a story. It’s not something I aim for, but it is a reminder that we are a small fish in a big ocean. It is undeniably frustrating sitting on information that should arguably be printed, but, in this student sphere, it’s not always worth risking the position of the paper, our sources, who are often friends, or ourselves for the sake of a story.

The Rafiki in the situation would say  that news isn’t worth publishing on such a small platform if it does no one any favours. Short of putting bunnies and flowers on the front page week on week, we will inevitably offend for one reason or another, but will hopefully learn to pick our battles.

In the meantime, we can always take refuge in the design-y, gooey middle bit. Oh hello, Indigo.