New Year, New-meat free me? Why going cold turkey on all meat-free products doesn’t have to be your jam

By  Izzy Sasada

Are you doing more cardio? Cutting back on paddies? Spending less time binge-watching Netflix? Many people use the new year as a period of reset: “new year, new me right?”

The beginning of 2019 brings a tide of New Year’s resolutions, with many aiming to cut back on unhealthy habits and saving money after Christmas festivities, and “Veganuary” is no exception.

Vegans have rebranded themselves as radiant and inclusive advocates of the ethical and healthy lifestyle movement, and they are challenging meat-eaters to join in by trying a vegan plant-based diet for a month. We’ve been here before with faddish food trends – we’ve seen the paleo, the keto and the atkins to name but a few, all hailed as the dietary solution during their brief 15 minutes in the limelight; but veganism claims to offer a complete solution, cutting out all meat products in the name of animal cruelty, environmental concerns and health benefits.

Social media is playing an important part in spreading the hype – there are over 400,000 #veganuary posts on Instagram as well as countless online support groups to track progress and share recipe ideas. Food industry players have caught on to the trend with Greggs releasing a “vegan sausage roll”, McDonald’s adding a veggin Mcwrap to its menu and Pizza Hut bringing out a vegan pizza.

The benefits seem clear. As well as sparing needless animal cruelty in agricultural practices and reducing the damage we are inflicting on the environment, Veganuary’s website lists endless health benefits of a balanced vegan diet, helping with weight loss, cutting blood pressure and lowering levels of type 2 diabetes. Phoebe Hagen, vegan PPE 2nd year attests to the health benefits of going vegan even for a short spell:

“My skin got clearer and I have more energy. I used to have hayfever and since going vegan I no longer have it. I get sick less and have better digestion.”

 

It’s debatable whether going cold-turkey on all meat products for 31 days is a sustainable way to cut your intake of animal products

However, it’s debatable whether going cold-turkey on all meat products for 31 days is a sustainable way to cut your intake of animal products. I have nothing but respect for full-time vegans, but there are certainly some faddish qualities about Veganuary. From Instagram influencers posting pictures of green shakes and Buddha bowls with the caption ‘nom nom’ #ad, to the social media frenzy following Greggs’ release of the vegan sausage roll, my concern is that veganism will join the “Atkins” “Keto and “Paleo” in the dustbin of long-forgotten trends.

I have nothing but respect for full-time vegans, but there are certainly some faddish qualities about Veganuary

The usefulness of month-long goals such as Veganuary and dry January are put into question if February 1st is met with binges and the partakers soon return to their old ways. So perhaps instead of completely cutting out all meat-produce for a month, it is more sustainable to make smaller, gradual changes. I urge part-time vegans to remember their motives behind Veganuary. If the main concern is animal rights, why should this mean you can’t eat cage-free eggs or sustainably sourced salmon? If health is a concern, why put your body at risk of B12 deficiency? Be realistic about your goals – in our market society, a big mac meal is cheaper than a punnet of strawberries and the influencers and celebrities advocating veganism have more resources to put towards their diet.

Challenges like “veganuary” are a great way to challenge yourself, but they are rendered worthless if they are reversed on February 1st

Challenges like “veganuary” are a great way to challenge yourself, but they are rendered worthless if they are reversed on February 1st.  Instead, perhaps a more gradual approach is more realistic and will result in longer lasting differences which have a bigger impact on the environment and on your health than a short term spell.

Illustration by Anna Thomas