New Perspectives: Send the aid where it’s needed
by Tobias Thornes
There can be no doubt that Britain is in a prime position from which to help other nations: we are endowed with plentiful resources, and although they are not shared out as equally as they could be, at least we have enough food, water, shelter and medicines to maintain our populace in a state of relative prosperity.
Yet, still, some voices continue to urge the government to reduce or deny aid to those parts of the globe which face spectres of starvation and thirst, in order to save a little more money to be poured into the black hole of ‘reducing the deficit’. David Cameron’s refusal to heed these voices this week, maintaining our commitment to 0.7 per cent of GDP in foreign aid, is good news for the world.
But at the same time there is genuine cause for concern as to how the money we give to foreign regimes is spent. This is a difficult issue, and one which the government is not apparently putting much effort into resolving: how do we bring about global wellbeing without globalisation?
Worryingly, the motivation for giving foreign aid is increasingly being attached to furthering the ‘brand’ of Great Britain, stamping our name on food-aid packaging and proudly proclaiming ‘your wellbeing is thanks to Britain’ to the starving and the thirsty that we help to feed in parts of the world where food yields – whether due to corruption or inhospitable conditions – are too poor to maintain the population. It is right that we should make the extent of our giving as a nation public so that other countries can follow our lead. But the furtherance of our own reputation should never be the motivation for giving of what we have to those who have not.
Furthermore, the notion that it is we who are somehow saving the ‘developing’ world from ills of their own or nature’s making is a fallacy. The reality is that we in the western world have a responsibility to provide aid to struggling countries in Africa and Asia, because it was us that created the problems they face in the first place.
When the empire-builders of the eighteenth and nineteenth century came across unindustrialised lands to the south and east, they set themselves on a mission to ‘improve’ upon the civilisations that they found there, by teaching these ancient peoples to mimic the European way of life.
Life wasn’t necessarily easy for the peoples of these lands before the colonists, but still they had survived for centuries, developing in their own manner and adopting imported practices as they saw fit, according to what would best fit their own culture and environment. The European empires tore this world apart, seeing it as their duty to impose upon these ‘less developed’ peoples their own systems of transport and agriculture, and encouraging urbanisation. Meanwhile, they could extract the natural resources of these countries – be it Indian tea or African diamonds – for their own benefit.
The empires may be no more, but the western world continues to follow the misguided practice of globalisation to this day. When independence came abruptly in the mid-twentieth century, the half-westernised African and Asian nations were unable to return to their former ways of living, because the traditional societal structures had been broken down by their subjection to imperial rule. Instead, the new regimes that replaced the colonialists were constructed based on a European model in cultures to which it was not suited.
Hence, from Mugabe in Zimbabwe and apartheid in South Africa, to the corrupt government of India; the newly liberated world gradually collapsed into tyranny. The inability of these regimes to run their countries effectively is what has resulted in such terrible conditions of famine and thirst in many parts of Africa and Asia today. Medicines and technologies that extend lives have been provided without those that allow family planning, resulting in a chronic crisis of overpopulation. Shanty-towns set up by the poor are bulldozed to make way for western-style apartment blocks. It is a situation that we, with our misguided attempts to ‘develop’ the rest of the world to be like ourselves, helped to create, and therefore one that we have the responsibility to help to remedy.
Therefore, we must continue to give considerable aid to less fortunate parts of the globe, which were by and large led onto the path of ruin as part of our drive to enrich our own country over past centuries. But we must be careful neither to fund the corrupt governments that still exist in many of the former colonies, nor to repeat the mistakes of our forebears by investing in the ‘development’ of other countries into copies of ourselves.
Western corporations should not be allowed to create factories or outlets in the so-called ‘developing’ world on the premise of fostering ‘economic growth’, squeezing yet more profit out of already beleaguered peoples and degrading their cultural identities. Instead, we should send provisions to the people who really need them – food, water and the funds to educate themselves and forge their own countries’ futures – to the starving who have been let down by their past and present governments.
Rather than patronising perfectly capable societies with the notion that we know what’s best for them, we must allow the people of the third world to choose the course of their own country’s future, irrespective of the benefit or harm to British business or the British ‘brand’. This will take more than 0.7 per cent of GDP. It’ll require a sustained investment of time and effort on the part of our own society. But both the wellbeing and cultural independence of millions of people depends on its provision.
Photograph: Parliamentary copyright images are reproduced with the permission of Parliament

