New Perspectives: Forgetting Growth – The Path to Prosperity

64george

by Tobias Thornes

Behind the proposals of both sides of the House of Commons, alas, lies the same basic fallacy. Both government and opposition, it seems, are intent on measuring the success or failure of a policy by the single, poorly chosen yardstick of economic growth. For Chancellor Osborne and his accomplices, the path to such growth is one of increased austerity for the majority, who must face the axing of so many of the services society has created for their benefit, in order that the rich lenders to which the country has become indebted might be more quickly repaid.

The richest gain what they desire – money – whilst the poorest loose what they truly need, which is help and support to obtain material necessities and inclusivity within a sharing society. Labour, meanwhile, prescribes investment in job creation and construction as though these were ends in themselves, proposing that consuming for the sake of consuming will ‘kick-start’ growth in the economy and restore the fortunes of the country.

But in taking such a capitalistic, consumption-based stance the party ventures far from the vision of its original ideals, to create a state of increased prosperity for the ordinary working person. For the true ‘fortunes’ of the country are not dependent on growing the economy, extracting more and more resources to build more and more urban metropolises and buy and sell more and more material goods.

The real test of a good society is whether it can provide a spiritual fulfilment – a sense of wellbeing and contentment – amongst its members. It should share its resources and its responsibilities, making each individual feel an important part of a greater whole. This was the original impetus behind the programme of nationalisation implemented by former Labour administrations: the switch from private to public engenders a spirit of mutual caring that goes far beyond the redistribution of material wealth and power that providing public rather than paid access to services can also entail.

The sad truth is that even the ‘left’ of British politics has, in recent years, fallen foul of the sort of capitalist propaganda that seems to be holding sway at this time, a myth that the greatest prosperity for the country comes about when it is producing and using as much as it can. Upsurges in spending and demand for new products are celebrated and encouraged in a manner seemingly oblivious to the environmental and social harms such a rampant throw-away culture creates.

The recent loss of Britain’s ‘triple A’ financial rating should certainly be regarded as an embarrassment for George Osborne and the Conservatives, given that their stated aim has been to improve the country’s financial outlook, and in this they have surely so far failed. But if we are to construct a truly prosperous society, we must abandon all focus on such financial measures and turn our attention to the true ills that we face.

Good government is not about public service austerity versus monetary investment. It’s about providing what people need to live out fulfilled and varied lives.

The fact is that having a large national debt, which is borrowed cheaply and at low interest, is of no concern to most people in our society. Money, after all, is a human invention: a convenience used to take account of the spread and exchange of resources, and certainly not something that we should allow to dictate the course of our country’s development.

Following the Second World War, Britain’s national debt was a far higher proportion of ‘gross domestic product’ than at present, and yet it was at just that time – when the Conservative voices of today would, no doubt, have advocated the strictest austerity in the hope of protecting their own monetary prospects – that the country created one of its most cherished and successful shared institutions, the NHS.

Of course, the government realises that there is no real need for austerity and for ‘cutting the deficit’ with all the haste it would have us believe is necessary. The Conservatives are really attempting to use the current crisis of capitalism as an excuse to increase privatisation and individualism, because they fear these very concepts – the shared ownership of our forests, the NHS and now even the publically-run fire service – that make our country a worthwhile and friendly place in which to live.Their belief is that their cherished economic growth will come about if the monetarily rich are given more power and freedom to do as they choose, the whole of society turned into a vast web of competing interests with the most able – or most fortunate – rising to the top in terms of both wealth and prosperity.

In light of this, the government is quite happy to see the opposition distracted from the sort of nation-changing ideas of nationalisation that erupted into actuality in that optimistic time following the war. Through finance-focused economic arguments they have forced the Labour left into seemingly conceding that ‘some cuts must be made’, because this justifies all the more in the mind of the public their programme of unprecedented destruction of some of the cherished foundations of our society. It is only through the work of activist groups such as 38 degrees, willing to take a long-term perspective of what really matters for our country, that some of the government’s most extreme attempts have been prevented from coming to fruition.

I have set out, in other contributions to this blog, some of the ways in which our society is in need of real change, in order to bring about wellbeing, equality and general fulfilment in life for the majority, concepts that are by no means wedded to material wealth. Such a state is one that allows change, when we find better ways of doing things, as well as individual diversities of monetary incomes, working hours and leisure pursuits, so long as all are provided with the basic things they need to live well. Some sectors may grow, others may shrink, as we seek to reach a stable state making the best use of the precious natural resources we have.

If we are to bring about such a new world of cooperation, in place of the cold, environmentally unsustainable and socially unsatisfactory consumerist culture in which we currently live, we must abandon the search for net economic growth as an end in itself. Good government is not about public service austerity versus monetary investment. It’s about providing what people need to live out fulfilled and varied lives without the threat of disaster should they become short of money, which should be returned to its place as an added extra when food, water, health and shelter have already been freely given. We need to make an intellectual investment, regardless of the financial cost, if we are to avert disaster, break out of the current money-based paradigm and start our world afresh.

Photograph: M. Holland