New Perspectives: Building the True ‘Big Society’

by Tobias Thornes

From David Cameron’s infamous idea of the ‘big society’, to Ed Milliband’s new notion of ‘one nation’, there’s been a strong appetite in politics recently to appeal to voters’ desire to feel part of something bigger.

Most likely, the rhetoric has been adopted in an attempt to counter a general feeling of contempt towards those we have put in power – be it in the banks or on the benches of Parliament – following the various financial and political crises of recent times. After all, the 2010 general election results showed that no party has succeeded in winning much respect from the electorate, and Tory policies, Labour personalities and Lib Dem promises all seem to have fallen short of the public’s desires.

But what we truly need from our leaders is surely not simply a set of hand-waving commitments towards a general, undefined ‘oneness’. In order to fully prosper together as a fair and sustainable society, we require a truly radical overhaul of the way things are currently done. Equality, freedom, fairness: these are the universal desires to which the prominent politicians are appealing with their words, and yet none of their actions come close to the change that is required to achieve these aims.

Take the ‘big society’. The policies behind this incongruous title are not designed to encourage us to come together behind a common goal, as the name first suggests. Instead, Cameron’s slashing of public service resources has served to further the Conservative aim of leaving the essential needs of society for individuals to obtain for themselves, of creating a world where the monetarily poor have to rely on the generosity of private charities in order to survive. It is an idea based on the misnomer that there is a conflict between ‘government’ and ‘society’, when in fact the government should be the servant of society, put in place to curb the excesses of inequality that would be brought about by unchecked individualism.

The government in truth represents the ultimate cooperative movement, in which everyone is involved. Cameron’s ‘big society’ – really an acronym for ‘big individual’ – seeks to erect the cruel misery of unforgiving competition for resources and unequal wellbeing in its place. In cutting public expenditure, the Conservatives hope to pay off some of the national debt we owe to wealthy organisations and individuals. Theirs is the ultimate Robin-Hood antithesis, stealing from the resources most vital to the poor, to pay off debts owed to the rich.

But a scarcely more appetising picture has been put forward by the Labour party, which, entrapped almost as much as the Conservatives by capitalist aims, is equally eager to promote ‘economic growth’ more than anything else. Its only criticisms to the current government have been revolving around its inability to provide this growth.

The ‘one nation’ idea lacks depth, and does not appear able to truly reunite a society currently split into higher and lower classes. Miliband’s talk of a ‘shared destiny’ and a ‘common life that we lead together’ speaks of a dramatic shift in society, but he has so far failed to commit to any fundamental changes to the way in which things are done, making only small pledges about encouraging employers to train more apprentices and enforcing the minimum wage. These are positive ideas, but they are unlikely to bring to reality the visions of a new dawn invoked by his grand descriptions of a country where ‘prosperity is fairly shared’.

Miliband did at least briefly allude to an historic figure he would do well to learn from. At this time of crisis, when our environment is being destroyed by the wastefulness of the monetarily rich, and the poor are left unemployed and unenthused.  At a time when the even poorer abroad are worked to the death to produce cheap, unnecessary goods, it is the spirit of Clement Attlee’s 1945 government that today’s politicians need to rekindle. Then, it was a Britain – and a world – devastated by industrial-scale warfare that needed rebuilding. Now, it is a land exhausted by capitalist excess.

The solutions, though, are similar. We urgently need a programme of renationalisation to bring the goods and services that the nation requires back into the nation’s own hands. We all know that we can do better: better public transport, better hospitals, better distribution of good-quality food, education and care to those that need them. Better-designed houses that require less energy, better-designed greener cities, towns and villages that make the use of the car unnecessary for the majority of the population.

Above all, we need a better-designed value system, one in which the amount of money in your bank account ceases to be so important, because all the essentials we each need to live are provided free of charge, since no just society can allow any one of its members to go without them. Yes, we’d still need money – we’d still work for cash and buy and sell those extra things that make life interesting. But there’d be no reason for anyone to go without the basics, and the emphasis would no longer be put on earning as much as possible in order to spend as much as possible, whatever the cost to the planet.

There’s no need for a redistribution of monetary wealth, but rather a redistribution of power and wellbeing – so that the penniless is fed, sheltered and educated as thoroughly as the millionaire, with just as much political clout. Nationalised industries would only grow so big as to meet the needs of society without crossing the limits of sustainability.

It may seem a pipe dream. Indeed, there is a lot of work to do in building a nation that is truly united. But we have a whole plethora of people – currently employed and unemployed – waiting to play their part in making it happen. Let’s be clear: this is no call for an October Revolution. What’s needed is a gradual programme of change to bring us out of the grip of the markets and into a situation where the resources available to us are distributed according to logic and need, not the confidence and greed of monetary investors. But politicians who truly want to improve well-being in this country need to start turning their abstractions into reality soon, before it’s too late not only for the current generation of humanity, but for those yet to come.

Photograph: Ben Fisher/GAVI Alliance