New drug and alcohol rehab centre on Whinney Hill upsets residents

by Jillian Ward

The construction of a Drug and Alcohol Treatment Centre on Whinney Hill is expected to be completed at the beginning of the new year, sparking controversy among the surrounding residential community.

The plan to move the centre from Claypath to numbers 81 to 88 on Whinney Hill was granted in September by Durham County Council’s planning committee. The plans were approved by five votes to three.

An NHS press release justified the move as providing “better facilities for service users and staff” and that the close proximity to the prison “will strengthen the positive links with our criminal justice partners, provide greater health outcomes for service users and a reduction in offending within our communities.”

Liberal Democrat County Councilor for Elvet, David Freeman, was one of the three who voted against the proposal to move the centre. The main reason for his opposition, he told Palatinate, is that a rehabilitation centre is “not a suitable development for a residential area.”

The plans also received opposition from the Whinney Hill Community Group in March. The group complained it should have been more involved in the discussions surrounding the move.

Freeman also claimed that the centre will inhibit residential development in the area. He said that the old school site on Whinney Hill across from the prison was “trying to get a developer to build new domestic properties” on it, but that “since planning permission was granted for the [rehabilitation] centre the chosen developer for the old school site has withdrawn interest.”

Freeman also emphasised a rise in fear of crime among residents, as “the Drug and Alcohol Treatment Centre is to deal with a large number of clients each day, most of whom have a criminal record.”

The fear of crime is thought to rise especially amongst “the old people who live in The Hallgarth”, flats between Whinney Hill and Hallgarth Street.

Irene Clarke, an elderly woman living alone on Whinney Hill, agreed that she is “not very happy” about the building of the centre due to a feared increase in crime rates. “You get more cautious when you’re older,” she added.

Councilor David Freeman believes the centre is “not a suitable development for a residential area.”

However, the NHS press release notes there “is often a misconception around treatment centres and the services they provide and we are working hard to reduce the stigma around drug use and demonstrate the value of these services […] for the wider community.”

Students do not seem to be as fearful of a rise in crime associated with the centre. Siri Minsaas, a second-year International Relations student and resident of Whinney Hill, told Palatinate: “I don’t see how it would lead to any more crime, because we’re right next to a police station, which is a pretty stupid place to commit a crime.”

William Garrison, a third-year Maths student who lives on Whinney Hill, told Palatinate: “I’m not bothered, to be honest.” His housemate and second-year Engineering student, Michael Stewart, said that he is not afraid of an increase of crime as “nobody does drugs on Whinney Hill.”

Mark Harrison, joint commissioning manager for the public health drug and alcohol commissioning team, defended the centre as being “covered by CCTV cameras”, adding that “all visits would be by appointment.”

Lyndsey Waters from Durham City Council told Palatinate that the Council “will not receive any more petitions or complaints” about the opening of the centre.

Photograph: Rose Innes