New diplomas won’t impress
FOUR OUT OF TEN top UK Universities would be unlikely to admit students who studied the new 14-19 Diploma instead of A-Levels, a survey has found. The research, carried out by the 1994 Group of major research universities in Britain, including Durham, Exeter, St. Andrews and Warwick, revealed that many admissions tutors would be less likely to admit candidates who are in possession of a Diploma.
The news comes as a blow to the government, who are currently using wide-spread advertising campaigns to promote the new Diplomas. The qualification will be introduced into 1,300 selected schools later this year, and will offer students from 14 to 19 the chance to study more vocational subjects.
Diploma subjects include Engineering, Creative and Media and Information Technology, and can be studied at three different levels – foundation, higher or advanced. By 2010, students will have the choice of 14 subject areas.
The new qualifications are being promoted as an alternative to A-Levels for all students, but are seen as a liability by many universities.
Admissions tutors say that they are in favour of the idea of the Diplomas but that they need to be more targeted – “No currently-proposed Diploma has the right focus,” said one tutor. Another also expressed doubt in the new qualification, saying, “I would be unhappy to admit students just on the strength of their Diploma.”
The reaction of universities to the Diploma could eventually result in a two-tier system where A-Levels are seen as more prestigious than the ‘softer’ vocational options that the Diplomas offer. There is already some dispute about how to integrate the new Diploma into the existing system so that there is no overlapping with the structure of A-Level courses. Implementing the new qualification will require co-operation and communication between schools, universities and the government, and the results of this latest research show that there is still a lot of work to be done.
