New big gifts policy does not include ethics committee

Chris-Higgins-poor-quality

by Justin Villamil

Durham University has recently released a new big gift donations policy, minimising the role of the University ethics committee.

The big gift donations policy is a document providing the guidelines for reviewing and accepting high-value donations. Specifically, it establishes a hierarchy of people who must be consulted in the event of a donation above a certain amount.

The biggest difference between the old and the new policies is that the ethics committee will no longer be consulted.

Decisions over whether donations should be accepted will now be made by the council alone.

Under the current policy, gifts of up to £250,000 may be accepted provided the Director of Development and Alumni Relations and the Director of the Office of Principal Gifts do not have any issues.

Gifts which amount to between £250,000 and £1 million must pass through the Deputy Vice-Chancellor, Registrar, and Treasurer before being accepted.

Anything above this amount must go through the Vice-Chancellor.

All gifts above £10,000 must be submitted for the approval of the council.

While previously the university would occasionally contact the ethics committee for rulings on specific donations, the updated policy does not allow for such consultations.

“Before the adoption of the current Gifts Policy the advice of the Chair of the Ethics Committee was occasionally sought in relation to particular gifts,” Paulina Lubacz, the Treasurer and Acting Registrar told Palatinate.

She added, “That arrangement was superseded by the current Gifts Policy. The Ethics Committee has never had a formal role in gift acceptance.”

The University declined, however, to give a specific reason for the change.

The most recent change to the big gift donations policy, which was voted upon last year, follows two high-profile donations in 2010 and 2011 which both led to widespread criticism.

In 2010, the University actually overruled the ethics committee and accepted a donation from
British American Tobacco, which amounted to the sum of £125,000. The donation funded scholarships for five Afghan postgraduate women.

Later, in April 2011, the University accepted a gift of £2.5 million from Sheikh Nasser Al-Sabah, the former Prime Minister of Kuwait, who had resigned amidst a corruption scandal. Sheikh Nasser was later cleared of corruption charges, and the money went to fund a postgraduate research programme.

However, the University and Vice-Chancellor Chris Higgins did not escape criticism.

The new policy outlines several ‘Caution Topics.’ Namely, any donors who take greater than 10% of their profits from arms manufacture, tobacco, alcohol, gambling, or pornography are deemed ‘Caution Topics’ and must be referred to the Council.

Similarly, any donors facing ‘public criticism’ or any individuals connected with abuses of human rights, child labour, anti-competitive practices, or environmental responsibility make the ‘Caution Topics’ list.

Lubacz believes this system will help Durham take advantage of more gifts in the future.

“Philanthropy is an increasingly vital part of the funding of Durham University and will enable us to sustain our academic goals into the long term,” Lubacz told Palatinate.

The ethics committee chair, the Very Reverend Michael Sadgrove could not be reached for comment.

Some students take issue with a perceived rejection of the ethics committee.

“I think it’s a bit suspect,” a University College first year who preferred not to be identified by name told Palatinate.

“I just don’t understand why they would feel the need to get rid of the ethics committee.”

Photograph: Durham University