Netflix’s Fyre Festival Documentary

By Martin Shore

Everyone knows that the Fyre Festival was a monumental failure, but Netflix’s new documentary Fyre: The Greatest Party that Never Happened aims to systematically break down how and why the festival collapsed.

Being a Netflix product, naturally, Fyre is well-paced and will keep you engaged through an impressive variety of content.  Narratively, the doc centres around the figure of Billy McFarland (the managing director of the Fyre brand), beginning and later returning to him as the arbiter of failure for his entire company.

It is arguably the presentation of Billy that director Chris Smith has nailed so well

Utilising McFarland’s obsession with having everything “behind-the-scenes” of the festival documented by his camera crew, we are given a bunch of testimonials to chart his personal trajectory through the film. First, we’re told how charismatic a leader and entrepreneur he was, being shown a variety of raucous parties from the hugely successful marketing period of the festival, before moving through his inability to listen to and work with his staff, and then the final third moves into more of an exposé of his own financial corruption, money laundering, defrauding investors and so on.

Billy is established first as this uniquely likeable character, before the documentary considerately peels back layers and layers to prove just how warped his vision of the entire party was.

Anchoring the entire failure so closely to Billy is definitely a smart move, for it gives the documentary an obvious “antagonist” for us to hate

The viewer is left with the sneaking suspicion that there must be some level of culpability for McFarland’s other employees. After all, the final shots of two members of the Fyre team are them telling viewers that they themselves are being sued by American Express for defaulted payments on their personal accounts, all of which went towards the Fyre festival. These workers must have at least been somewhat invested in the festival to allow themselves to become so invested in the scam artist operating at the top.

It’s important to note, however, that the axis of sympathy is not directed towards the attendees of the festival, either. There are a group of guests interviewed alongside footage of the genuine carnage once guests arrived on the festival beachfront (which was little more than a housing or resort development plot on the Bahamian island of Great Exuma), none of which paint the millennial attendees. We’re told guests started looting supplies and resources to stockpile in their tents, that they were sabotaging tents surrounding their own because ‘they didn’t want neighbours’ and show general disgust for having to share their promised “private jets” with other guests which were ‘worse than, like, low, low economy.’ It’s easy to dislike the people you’re being shown, especially seeing their self-interest emerge when realistically they could have tried to help one another, but it must be said that these guests did pay a minimum of $8,000 just to attend the festival. Whether or not you’re satisfied by seeing the veneer of the “Insta-famous” fall away in favour of more self-indulgent, self-absorbed characters, this was a very legitimate crisis. We’re meant to understand how they were treated, but not necessarily empathise with them, but moreso the organisers who evidently had no clue what they were doing.

I did particularly enjoy that the documentary dedicated some time to the Bahamian workers who were completely exploited by McFarland’s gang

Fyre Festival could easily be summarised as an event held by a fraudulent start-up founder, advertising the performative rich, luxurious lifestyle that middle-to-upper-class American influencers, software entrepreneurs and social media stars show off every day. The only difference is, it’s a party in the Bahamas with no real care for those grassroots workers who were exploited to build his line of “luxury” tents. Mcfarland enlisted hundreds of Bahamian labourers to construct the festival on the promise of huge working opportunities and earning potential. They go unpaid, demand their payment as the festival starts going south, and thus everybody leaves, without reparations to the island. The Fyre team ruined the lives of so many people, a point artfully captured by the owner of one of the restaurants, who spent her life savings of $50,000 to keep her staff working around the clock to feed McFarland’s guests. This is one of the most touching moments of the documentary, a bleak reminder that there are real-world consequences to the gross misconduct of one man.

Fyre: The Greatest Party That Never Happened is an entertaining and intriguing deep-dive into the psyche of a money-hungry megalomaniac and the complete disaster that he organised

Well structured and impactful, it deserves a watch if you’re at all interested in the behind-the-scenes of 2017’s most famous failures.

Image Credit: pixabay