Netanyahu loses electoral majority in Israel

By John Inglis-Jones

In October 27th election, Netanyahu’s right-wing bloc scored 53 seats, losing 15 and thus the majority (61 out of 120 seats). Eisenkot’s bloc scored 48 seats. The third major pillar, the Arab-led parties, won a record-breaking 19 seats. The anti-Netanyahu factions hold a combined 67 seats but haven’t yet formed a government. Arab Centre analysis has stated that 70% of Jewish Israeli’s oppose including an Arab party in a coalition, and Eisenkot set specific conditions for any coalition partner which most Arab lawmakers would be unlikely to formally accept. Whilst Netanyahu’s coalition is out of a majority, it is not out of office, and the seats opposed to him can only govern if someone breaks a campaign promise. The question is what drove voters to strip Netanyahu of his majority, and why that fell short of removing him.

The October 7th attack dominated the campaign, bringing public dissatisfaction with national security to a head. A pre-election Israel Democracy Institute poll reported that over 60% of Israelis said their attitudes to October 7th were a central factor in how they would vote. Netanyahu, the only senior figure from that day still in office, has repeatedly rejected calls for an official inquiry, which Eisenkot made a central pledge in his campaign. The war in Gaza has exacerbated societal fractures especially over ultra-Orthodox draft exemptions, which the Supreme Court has ruled unconstitutional. Netanyahu’s government depends on Haredi parties, who wanted the exemptions kept. This tension is reflected through the electoral results with Shas falling from 11 seats in 2022 to 6, its lowest since 1988. Netanyahu has also been on trial since 2020 for corruption.

Dominated the campaign, bringing public dissatisfaction with national security to a head

Nonetheless, Netanyahu retains substantial support. Likud remains the largest party with 27 seats against Yashar’s 21, and Netanyahu remains one of Israel’s most experienced political operators, benefiting from his security-focused politics. His defenders say he was betrayed by the military establishment and has led a dramatic rebound. The result suggests voters punished his coalition without rejecting him.

This political gridlock matters because the ceasefire’s second phase, covering Hamas’ disarmament, Israeli withdrawal and reconstruction, has stalled over sequencing. Netanyahu refuses to pull forces back from the Yellow Line, which would leave Israel holding just over half of Gaza, until Hamas is genuinely disarmed, arguing it would otherwise rearm. On the other hand, a senior Hamas official said that the group would disarm only if Israel withdrew first. Envoy Jared Kushner blamed the Israeli election campaign for the stall, saying it made the government “a little irrational”. His right-wing base opposes the US plan with no withdrawal, so a Netanyahu-led government would rely on partners who can facilitate this resistance. A change of government would not necessarily soften Israel’s stance. Eisenkot says the war failed because Hamas remains in charge and has pledged to destroy its military and governing power within 18 months. Until a government forms, Netanyahu remains caretaker and his disarmament-first position stays Israel’s official stance, leaving the ceasefire in place but its second phase frozen.

Until a government forms, Netanyahu remains caretaker and his disarmament-first position

The deadlock also tests the US-Israeli relationship. The strategic alliance itself looks secure, since Israel’s leading parties all share the aim of countering Iran, Hamas and Hezbollah, but the personal channel Netanyahu campaigned on until recently is in question. Netanyahu rejected the Board of Peace’s roadmap, and he and Trump diverged over Iran, a war they launched together in February, when Trump sought a ceasefire as the conflict hurt his popularity and raised oil prices. Trump insists the relationship between them remains “very good”, yet while Netanyahu remains caretaker, Atlantic Council analyst Daniel Shapiro warns he could resume the Iran war, which would run counter to Trump’s push for a settlement.

In summary, the election was a rebuke without a resolution. Voters stripped Netanyahu of his majority but not his office, and a government can form only if Eisenkot accepts the Arab-party’s support or the two blocs agree to a unity deal. Until one side yields, the ceasefire’s second phase stays frozen, and the strain in US-Israeli ties remains unresolved.

Image: Beny Schlevich via Wikimedia Commons