Navalny’s gambit: Why has the poisoned opposition leader returned to Russia?
By Nikita Furley Artamonov
Alexei Navalny. You might have heard of him. On 20th August last year, the Russian opposition leader made headlines across the world after being poisoned with the nerve agent ‘Novichok’ on a flight from the Siberian city of Tomsk. The plane made an emergency landing and Navalny, already in a coma, was taken to a local Siberian hospital. After some delay, Navalny was evacuated to Germany for treatment, where he has been staying and recuperating until now. Navalny is convinced and provided documentary evidence that the Kremlin was behind his attempted assassination. And yet, on Sunday, surrounded by a crowd of journalists, he flew back to Russia.
The story of Navalny is extraordinary – even by Russian standards. The lawyer, turned politician and anti-corruption activist, is no stranger to state repression. He has been arrested more times than you could count on both hands. Charges of fraud, widely considered to be politically motivated, were brought back from 2013 to scare him off coming back to Russia.
The brazen attempt at Navalny’s life in August was shocking, but unsurprising
And it is no wonder that he has made an enemy of himself to Putin’s circle. If Putin effectively controls the official news channels, Navalny has been more successful at harnessing the power of social media. Navalny’s highly popular YouTube videos investigate the systemic corruption of Russia’s ruling elite; they are scandalous exposés that fetch tens of millions of views, directly threatening the state’s legitimacy.
More than that, social media also provides Navalny with a platform for his political campaigning – promoting his tactical ‘Smart Voting’ strategy, which has successfully deprived the United Russia party of votes and seats in regional and federal elections. The United Russia party, or the ‘party of crooks and thieves’ as Navalny famously calls them, is Putin’s main tool of political control.
Many speculate that Navalny’s ‘Smart Voting’ campaign in the 2020 regional elections, combined with the timing – the unrest in nearby Belarus and anti-Putin protests in the Siberian city of Khabarovsk – pushed a paranoid state to extrajudicial murder. The brazen attempt at Navalny’s life in August was shocking, but unsurprising. This reaction is not unique: Navalny joins a long list of Kremlin critics fallen victim to the most extreme measures, from Alexander Litvinenko in 2006 to the Skripals in 2018.
It is a direct challenge to Putin, and the president has used up all his cards
But Navalny did not die. Not only did he survive and recover; in December, helped by the investigative agency Bellingcat, he provided strong evidence that the FSB (the KGB’s successor) had been behind his attempted assassination and even identified the agents involved. It gets better. Navalny, posing as an FSB official, called one of the operatives, Konstantin Kudryavtsev, and duped him into a detailed admission of the failed operation. All of this is on YouTube, there for millions to see. The Kremlin, as usual, denies everything, even suggesting among other explanations that Navalny poisoned himself.
What cannot be denied is that instead of solving the Navalny problem, things have gotten worse for Putin. Instead of silencing Russia’s top dissident, Navalny has been emboldened. His latest move to return to Russia on the 17th January, knowing full well the potential danger to his life, is a historic act. Navalny refuses to be scared into exile and submission. His decision to fly back to Russia with the airline “Victory” is symbolic.
It is a direct challenge to Putin, and the president has used up all his cards. Analysts have likened Navalny’s step to the chess move ‘Zugzwang’ – whatever the Russian authorities do now, they end up in a worse position than they were before. They cannot try to kill him again – the world is watching. They cannot ignore him – he is too much of a threat. And by jailing him, Navalny becomes a prisoner of conscience, a martyr for a just cause, and, just maybe, the next Nelson Mandela.
Sacrificing his freedom, Navalny has performed the highest act of bravery
If Navalny had given up and stayed abroad, all that he had fought for, suffered for and almost died for would have been for nothing. Navalny considers it his duty to disarm the regime of its spell of fear over the Russian people in the hope of triggering democratic change in Russia. Sacrificing his freedom and the future of his family, Navalny has performed the highest act of bravery.
Hugging his wife goodbye as police take him into custody, without his lawyer, Navalny announces: “I am not afraid”. His wife Yulya echoed his message as she left the airport without her husband: “Alexei is not afraid. I am not afraid. You shouldn’t be afraid either”.
Image: Vladimir Varfolomeev via Flickr

