National response to consent class criticism

Photograph: Garry Knight, Flickr
Photograph: Garry Knight via Flickr

By Siena Morrell

A Warwick University student last week attracted a maelstrom of controversy after publicly objecting to his invitation to a sexual consent class by saying that he does not need to be taught about rape – and that he doesn’t “look like” a rapist.

Politics and sociology student George Lawlor expressed his anger at being invited to participate in the workshop hosted by the Warwick Students’ Union, called ‘I Heart Consent.’

“To be invited to such a waste of time was the biggest insult I’ve received in a good few years,” Lawlor wrote. “It implies I have an insufficient understanding of what does and does not constitute consent and that’s incredibly hurtful.

“Brand me a bigot, a misogynist, a rape apologist, I don’t care. I stand by that,” he wrote. “I feel as if I’m taking the ‘wrong’ side here, but someone has to say it – I don’t have to be taught not to be a rapist.

“I don’t have to be taught to not be a rapist.”

Accompanying the article was a photograph of the author, bearing a handwritten sign with the words: “This is not what a rapist looks like.”

Writers for both student and national publications have responded officially to Lawlor’s comments, identifying that as the flaw in his reasoning.

Some students have leapt to Lawlor’s defense, with fellow Tab contributor Oli Dugmore writing: “George was doomed from the beginning. Because anyone who dares challenge the status quo of consent is set upon by the pack.”

Dugmore did, however, disagree with Lawlor in one respect: that just because he was a well-educated, self-proclaimed “decent, empathetic” individual, that he – and his friends – had no need for “help to understand basic human interaction.”

Journalist Rebecca Reid, writing in The Telegraph, echoed this criticism.

“Rapists are not a type. Rapists are not like pirates. They don’t dress a certain way or have a modus operandi.

“What Lawlor really doesn’t seem to quite grasp is that rapists don’t dress like the Hamburgler and hide in bushes.”

The Overview of Sexual Offending in England and Wales, released in January 2013 by the Ministry of Justice, the Office for National Statistics, and the Home Office, showed that approximately 90% of those who are raped know the perpetrator prior to the offence.

“So yes, a normal bloke is exactly what a rapist looks like,” Reid said.

Lawlor’s stand comes at a time when universities nationwide are recognising the importance of continuing sexual health education: Warwick follows Oxford and Cambridge in adding consent classes to the induction week timetable.

At Durham, however, the initiative has faltered. A poll run by The Tab Durham showed just 39% of 4,440 votes were in favour of introducing consent classes to the freshers’ week timetable.

Despite a motion passed last year by the Durham Students’ Union stating the need for compulsory consent workshops from September 2015, the complexity of the scheme has hindered a university-wide launch.

Adam Frost, a fourth-year linguist at Durham, said he considered Lawlor’s response to the classes “disproportionate” and “venomous” but insisted upon the need for a tactful approach to address consent, to avoid giving the impression that all men are rapists.

Last year, Frost attracted criticism for his attempts to establish a men’s rights society after the suicide of a friend. He was only permitted to establish the society as a branch of Durham University Feminism Society.

“Men are starting to get fed up of feminist generalisations about toxic masculinity,” Frost said to Palatinate. “It’s this sort of demonization by feminism that men are beginning to resent.”

This element of Lawlor’s article, that as a man, being invited to a consent class is tantamount to an accusation of being a “vile rapist-in-waiting,” has gained some traction.

“Selectively inviting people to attend them is a dangerous game,” wrote Oli Dugmore. “The rugby players of Oxford were singled out and made to attend compulsory classes on consent. Does that mean we assume they are rapists more than anyone else?”

The National Union of Students have targeted societies and sports teams with the I Heart Consent initiative.

Speaking to the BBC, Josie Throup, Women’s officer for Warwick Students’ Union and campus orchestrator of the workshops, said “I want to make it clear that we are not attacking sports teams.”

In an article for The Tab, Throup clarified her position.

“Warwick sports teams chant songs about rape. A friend of mine from a club here at Warwick told me about a pre-drinks in which members of his club raised their voices as one in the chant.

“An exec member who had attended an I Heart Consent workshop told them to stop, mindful of survivors in the room who would be traumatised, and perpetrators who would be empowered.

“Our workshops teach there’s a spectrum of misunderstandings in between, and consent can only be an enthusiastic yes,” wrote Throup.