National outrage at students’ fancy dress
By James Poole
University students from across the UK have this month sparked outrage from national newspapers for “inappropriate” fancy dress costumes.
Students from the universities of York, Edinburgh and London made headlines in the national media after costumes involved party-goers ‘blacking up’ to imitate racial stereotypes.
Earlier this month The Guardian reported that a group of male students from the University of York dressed as characters from the film ‘Cool Runnings’, in which a group of Jamaicans enters a bobsleigh competition, by wearing black morph suits, dreadlock wigs and black paint.
At a similar time, students from the Law Society at Edinburgh University were revealed in the Huffington Post to have painted their hands and faces brown to attend an ‘around the world’ themed party as Somalian Pirates.
The online newspaper also reported that a ‘Bad Taste’ party held earlier this year saw members of the rugby team at the University of East Anglia dress up as Joseph Kony and KKK extremists.
In another controversial case, the Evening Standard exposed how the University of London’s Union (ULU) hosted a fancy dress competition that was won by a male student wearing red devil horns with a blacked-up face.
The ULU, a union responsible for representing over 170, 000 students in one of the most ethnically diverse cities in the world, later announced that it was launching an official investigation into the event and condemned the student’s costume, saying: “What he was wearing was offensive. It is blacking up. There is no defence for blacking up.”
Aaron Kiely, the Black Students Officer at the National Union of Students responded to the news coverage, saying that “I’ve noticed that it’s happening more now. It’s deeply worrying because it fuels racial stereotypes about black people.”
He continued, “If you’re a black student walking around campus and you see people who have dressed up to mock you, what kind of environment does that make for people who want to learn?”
Amy-Jo Fletcher, a first year Law student at Durham, criticised the decision of students to ‘black up’, saying that “It’s absolutely shocking. Fancy dress should be about the fun of dressing up and wearing something silly, not causing serious offence.”
A first year English Literature student, Cat Crooke shared this view, arguing “this is cultural appropriation at its finest; you can’t put someone else’s culture on for a night.”
In contrast, Matt Clarke, a first year Geography student, struggled to see the cause for concern, arguing that “these social nights are just a bit of fun, people should be able to dress in what they like.”
Recent news coverage has also exposed the targeting of other sensitive issues through students’ fancy dress, with two Chester University students being named and shamed in the Daily Mail for winning a £150 prize in return for attending a Halloween event dressed as the Twin Towers being hit by planes.
Similarly, back in 2012 Palatinate reported on a Cuth’s Rugby social that saw students dress up as Jimmy Savile, his victims and the police, with the club’s most recent social, held on 17th October 2013, attracting equally bad press.
Sofia Hewson, a student at Durham University, raised concerns about the growing influence of ‘lad culture’ on student social nights and fancy dress, arguing that “in lad culture, racism and sexism can thrive. Students are in a bubble at university so some think they can do what they want.”
In response to the national outcry from newspapers and student figureheads, officers at Birmingham University’s student union have recently attempted to monitor student social nights and fancy dress by introducing a blanket ban on any costumes deemed to be racist from campus venues.
When asked how Durham’s students union could tackle the issue, James Sellens, a first year Law student, said that “the DSU needs to raise awareness of the offence that can be caused by student social nights and fancy dress.”
However, Peter Mathews, a first year Languages student, called for limited union involvement, saying that “there are bigger and much more important problems that the union could be dealing with.”
Photograph: Nicola Todhunter
