My clothes are never my consent

By Michelle Wisson

Michael Sanguinetti must still be biting his tongue as he watches the actions that he catalysed unfold.  This Toronto Policeman instructed female students at Osgoode Hall law school that “women should avoid dressing like sluts in order not to be victimised”, unleashing a debate about rape that has global significance and inspiring protests that started with 3,000 women in Toronto under the banner of the original “SlutWalk”, but that has spread as far afield as Melbourne and Delhi and become enthralled in controversy in the media.

The danger of these comments is that they are already embedded in judicial systems.  Estimates state that of the 2,000 women who are raped every week in Britain 95% of cases are not reported, with a conviction rate of only 6%.  This is linked to jurors basing their verdicts on what the defendant’s lawyer can argue about a woman’s choice of clothing, alcohol consumption and past sexual history. In these cases the responsibility of a rape is being shared by victim and perpetrator – a responsibility that cannot, by the definition of rape being against consent, be shared.

In a recent survey of London  students 17% of students said that women dressed in “sexy clothing” were at least partially responsible if they were raped.

As has been widely publicised, some women have chosen to dress provocatively on SlutWalks to prove the point that clothing choices do not entitle a man to rape them; their outfits are a visual statement that their consent to sex is an inalienable right and not a conditional one.

However, the media, in particular female commentators, have largely criticised this method of activism, arguing that rape is of course wrong, as is blaming the victims, but that stripping to “slutty” clothing to seek attention for this point establishes that women have to “get their kit off” to be heard, defining and celebrating women in a solely sexual manner.

Conversely, when I joined the London SlutWalk, the crowd was not exclusively young, female, or stupid. To patronise this perceived ignorance of SlutWalkers to grasp the feminist cause is simply ludicrous.   Signs such as “the virgin-whore dichotomy is getting old” appreciated the tone of the protest, which was exceedingly based on the inclusiveness of all women, angry at being labelled in certain ways because of their gender. A divergence of opinions is extremely symptomatic of the history of feminism and yet to protest was to engage in, at the least, a single message about seeking justice: “Whatever we wear, wherever we go, yes means yes and no means no.”

Debates about the sexualisation of women should look to how the most widely read newspaper in the UK puts a topless woman on the kitchen table every day or into the sexualised culture of music videos.  SlutWalk and our generation of feminists should not be blamed for the implications of the recent Bailey Report because some women chose to use sexual shock tactics to raise awareness. They used this tactic, not because it was the only way to be heard, but because it directly addressed Sanguinetti’s comments.

Moreover, the reporting has been largely selective and omitted looking beyond the first bra on the horizon.  The photographers focussed on the scantily-clad SlutWalkers while the protest really consisted of a diverse range of outfits, a splattering of men and, for the most part, normally dressed women from students to ladies well into their  50s.

The emotional poignancy of the protest has, unfortunately, largely been ignored by the papers.  Some women chose to wear the normal clothing they were raped in or pyjamas to represent rape that happens within the home.

Signs around me read “I was approached for rape at work in THIS dress” held by a woman in work-appropriate clothing, placards stated “in solidarity with all women hotel-workers” and a middle-aged woman quietly cried into her friend’s shoulder.  It was apparent to many who didn’t have editorial space to fill that the cause was much more painful for some protesters than any pain the media criticism could inflict.

In the toilets of a near by pub a woman removing her basque advised me about the best way to remove the lipstick “slut” from my face. In her thick American accent she proclaimed that “it was important to occur” and that today “we had occurred”.

We had chosen different outfits but equally made the same point, critical to feminism as it pivots on the most basic principle of equality that there is – the rule of equal protection under the law.  If even one juror questions his/her own assumptions about blame in rape cases then the “sluts” have taken a step forward and not backwards.