Musicals and making history: how might musicals influence modern perceptions of historical events?
By Alice Lim
What name comes to mind when you hear the phrase ‘historical musical’? The hip-hop musical Hamilton about the titular Founding Father and the pop-styled Six about Henry VIII’s six wives are two currently popular ones, but dozens upon dozens of them exist that range heavily in both style and subject. Historical musicals have experienced both critical and financial success, but a third factor contributes heavily to their longevity: the audience’s response to a historical story set to music, which has a large hand in how the story itself can be remembered. With this in mind, then, how do historical musicals influence modern perceptions of their content, and are there any pitfalls we should take care to avoid?
Firstly, historical musicals present events in ways that allow you to easily understand them – this is true for stories that are well known, obscure, and everything in between. In the case of Hamilton or Six, while a spectator might be familiar with the general context of the events, they may not know the specifics of what happened in those characters’ lives. The musical will take care to reenact some of those details for you, presenting them in an easily digestible manner. An audience member will thus have a good (if showtune-ridden) understanding of the version of events presented. But a pitfall makes its presence known here: how can the historical content of the musical be completely accurate to real life if played for dramatics?
The answer here is that it can’t be – or at least can never fully be. The fundamental goal of the musical itself is not to present history to historians, but the public, who expect a show and not a textbook chapter. What matters is not so much the history as it is the story, which will tell historical events in the ways it sees fit – of course, different musicals present historical content in all sorts of ways, but most musicals require an exaggeration of story to even be effectively communicated, especially if the addition of song risks making it seem less believable.
“What matters is not so much the history as it is the story, which will tell historical events in the ways it sees fit.”
This is accomplished with varying degrees of accuracy. Hamilton fulfills, in part, its historical expectations with its costume, staging, and narrative progression, but departs from this convention by having many of its songs be rapped through; Six, by comparison, keeps only the backgrounds of its main characters and sets the story entirely as a pop concert where characters, while competing in telling their 1500s backgrounds, humorously contrast this with modern phrasing (take, for example, Anne Boleyn: Everybody chill, it’s totes God’s will!) Both tell engaging stories and serve the purpose of informing the audience about the lives of their subjects – but the historical accuracy, while welcome, isn’t as necessary as the general implication of history.
Additionally, the historical musical usually has a message for its audience to comprehend, which may or may not reflect the historical content discussed, and may even assert its own view of historical events. Six takes the opportunity to place Henry’s wives in the spotlight, letting them assert their identities as individuals and not as a collective. One could, however, argue that this may lead the audience member to take the story at face value and ignore other narratives that remain unheard, as unfavorable parts of the characters’ histories may be glossed over entirely – controversies that cannot be used for character development in a work that intends for you to empathize with the heroes. While Hamilton promotes themes of freedom and independence while featuring characters of color prominently within its casting, this does not negate that their real world counterparts directly contributed to the history of slavery and appropriation in America.
“While Hamilton promotes themes of freedom and independence… this does not negate that their real-world counterparts directly contributed to the history of slavery and appropriation in America.”
Nonetheless, it must be reiterated that the musical is a vehicle for social commentary which presents history through a specific lens for its themes – the fuller context of which might not always suit what it wishes to express, although this is accomplished to varying degrees of effect. Furthermore, I would like to believe that audiences have enough common sense to not only be aware that they are watching a work of fiction, but that they can consume it with a clear separation from what is fictionalized and what has been overlooked – and, if sufficiently motivated and engaged, be inspired to take it upon themselves to find out more.
Ultimately, it is clear that an audience is extremely receptive of the modern directions musicals have taken towards historical events, but musicals do not, and cannot, reflect historical content completely accurately both for the sake of the narrative emotional impact and for their enjoyment of experience. Additionally, I believe that the audience not only takes into account the fictionality of the musical, but that their enjoyment does not distract them from wanting to learn more. Musicals are an introduction to history, but should not be treated as a masterclass.
“Musicals are an introduction to history, but should not be treated as a masterclass.”
Image Credit: The Telegraph

