‘Mulholland Drive’: The Cinema of Dreams

By Hugh Memess

David Lynch has a reputation for weirdness. This goes back to his first feature-length picture Eraserhead: an unearthly montage of industrial hellscapes, deformed children and severed heads. That said, to think of Lynch simply as a weird-monger, dealing in the strange and odd, is to do a disservice to him. His entire career has been spent refining a cinema that deals in dreams, images and music; that shuns words and “reality” to create surrealist films which look at the subconscious expressions of human feelings. With Mulholland Drive Lynch reached his peak, the ultimate expression of everything he’s attempted with the cinema.

The movie seems to be about Hollywood-hopeful Betty (Naomi Watts), recently arrived in the City of Angels, and Rita (Laura Harring), suffering from the duel shock of an attempt on her life followed by a car crash. Rita stumbles down the dark hills through the jagged trees to the glittering Hollywood beneath her, where she finds herself in Betty’s apartment. Rita is terrified, confused, and suffering from memory loss, unable even to remember her own name (“Rita” being picked up from a Gilda poster).

Plucky Betty decides to help, and the two embark on a kind of Famous Five  adventure in a quest to discover who Rita is and why she was carrying a handbag with $50,000 and a blue key inside. On the way they encounter gangsters and assassins – and fall in love. It almost sounds like a typical Hollywood movie; perhaps a noir from the 50s updated for the 21st century, with a lesbian couple instead of hardboiled Bogart and beautiful Bacall. Not so. The narrative never even begins to settle into such a safe formula. The first two hours are frantic and disparate, swirling through seemingly unrelated episodes with a terrifying and dream-like quality.

Lynch’s brilliance is in the creation of an unsettling, disconcerting tone which blurs dreams and reality, fantasy and horror. Everything all seems so familiar. The logic of the film is the logic of our dreams – the fears, frustrations, and desires that are universal to all of us, the same thoughts knocking around in our skulls when we sleep. In this crafting of a celluloid dream world, Lynch has created a piece of pure cinema that doesn’t depend on words or the conscious intellect; instead it is a work of music and images that moves you from feeling to feeling in a hypnotic rollercoaster through its protagonist’s subconscious. The logic of the movie, being unlike the logic of most films we’ll watch if we spend an average Saturday evening at the cinema, can seem confusing. I suggest that you should simply watch the movie, let it have its way with you, confuse and scare you, touch and excite you, before thinking about it too hard.

It’s easy to talk of movies in terms of just their director, but even if the whole were lesser it would still be worth watching for its ancillary parts. Naomi Watts’ performance must be one of the most technically proficient of the 21st century. Betty is simultaneously an archetype (of the naïve Hollywood starlet) and also a perfectly real person – the archetype given full form.

The lighting from Richard Deming (not normally thought of as a great cinematographer, the rest of his work being rather uninteresting) is perfect in supporting the complex shifts of dream and reality, creating a look for the film that perfectly understands Lynch’s goals. Cinematographically speaking, the highlight of the film and probably Deming’s career is a sequence in a nightclub about two thirds of the way through. The streetlights outside take on an otherworldly shimmer and give Betty and Rita’s skin a ghostly glow, while the nightclub itself seems to shift and change as the lights do.

The score of Lynch’s long-time collaborator Angelo Badalementi achieves a similar effect, being a richly woven tapestry of ethereal, ominous, and sensual tones and harmonies. Badalamenti (who has a cameo in the movie as a frighteningly obsessive coffee connoisseur) is distinct from other great film composers like Nino Rota and Bernard Herrmann. You wouldn’t want to listen to a Badalamenti piece out of context, and I can’t imagine wanting to have ‘Dwarfland’ come up on shuffle. Nevertheless, he might as well share a brain with Lynch; his compositions contribute so much to the feeling of the film.

The critics may well be right when they say Mulholland Drive is one of the best films of the past 16 years, but it will endure for much longer than that. Lynch’s handling of guilt, desire and dreams will live on as a marvel of human creativity as long as the film can be seen.

Photograph: peetlesnumber1