Much Ado About Nothing review: ‘brimming with talent’
By Nicki Orrell
I was excited to be able to see Much Ado About Nothing. With an extremely talented cast and production team, it could easily have been one of the best productions of the year. However, amateur mistakes and venue problems significantly let this production down.
There were many praiseworthy elements of the play. The Director, Kate Barton, should be incredibly proud of her dynamic, exciting blocking. She utilised the space very effectively, and brought out the full potential of the physical comedy within the piece. Furthermore, Leying Lee, the Producer, should be lauded for her beautiful and simple set. The 1940s setting worked wonderfully for the piece and the costumes were faultlessly within period. Finally, the entire ensemble was clearly talented and from what I could hear, had an excellent grasp of the meaning of their lines and the comedic effect they should be trying to achieve. The cadences achieved were musical and a lovely demonstration of classical delivery of Shakespeare.
It was a shame that this level of detail did not extend to all aspects of the production. Including a high-five in a Shakespearian piece set in the 1940s was an anachronistic oddity; sacrificing the tragic contrast the funeral was supposed to bring, to include the quick sign gag was a poor choice; and not aging Leonata, played by Abigail Weinstock, made her seem the same age as her daughter. Finally, the interval needs to have some sort of indication when it’s over, as the first conversation after it was essentially missed with audience continuing to chatter.
Some performances were exceptional; Theodore Holt-Bailey, stole the show as Benedict. Not only was he amusing, but his delivery of the lines had a casual naturalism that is really commendable with Shakespeare. Georgie Franklin matched him well as Beatrice, with a natural wit and likeable charm shining through. The main thing the pair could work on would be the chemistry between them, as this was sometimes lacking, such as during the incredibly awkward first hug they shared. Jenny Walser brought a very sassy spirit to the usually pallid, Hero. It was a delight to watch, as it made a character essentially used as a plot device someone likeable to root for. Sarah Slimani and Alex Prescot should also be commended for their brilliant comic acting, every facial expression, every action, and every movement was hilarious. Finally, Theo Harrison, playing Conrade, should be commended for his incredible stage presence- there was never a moment he was on stage and not completely in character.
Unfortunately, the acting suffered greatly in the party and ensemble scenes. There was a beautiful introduction of music and dance into the party scene that should have been carried on lightly in the background to continue an atmosphere of merriment. Instead the cast stood around awkwardly chatting to each other, which caused the energy to instantly die.
It must be said that Castle Great Hall is a difficult venue to perform in, the walls allow for huge amounts of echoing and reverberation. However, it was inexcusable that the cast did not try and take this into account. Lines were continually delivered with backs to the audience, or looking downwards. This, coupled with poor enunciation and projection left vast swathes of dialogue unintelligible. I only managed to catch twenty per cent or so of Claudio’s, played by Harvey Comerford, lines. For future performances enunciation must be clearer and lines need to be delivered facing directly forward in order for the audience closer to the back to have any chance of hearing them.
The most frustrating thing about this production is how brimming with talent and experience it very clearly is; this unfortunately makes the mistakes that hindered it so heavily, even more obvious. However, this is also the show’s saving grace, as there is a very easy trajectory of improvement to follow. With an outside performance hopefully happening today, and the tour perhaps offering better venues and more time to rehearse- this production has the potential to morph into something special.
Photograph: Leying Lee
