Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story – an insensitive money-grab revealing the inner monsters at Netflix

By William Daffern

Content warning: this article contains mentions of serial murder that may be upsetting to some readers

As I sat on my comfortable sofa writhing with discomfort and disgust at the gruesome murders depicted in the new Netflix series, Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story, I was dismayed to find that I could not take my eyes off the show. In fact, if it weren’t for the impending doom of a 09:00 am lecture the next morning, I almost certainly would’ve stuck on another episode. There is something very compelling about this horrific true crime series that draws us in for reasons we cannot articulate, and this is reflected by the huge success of the series on the streaming site.

As I was watching, I could not help but notice the lack of screen time dedicated to Dahmer’s victims, with the show clearly too infatuated with its star man. The first five episodes almost exclusively focus on Dahmer’s despicable deeds and his childhood, and it is this aspect of the show that I have a major issue with. Portraying Dahmer as the star of the show, whilst simultaneously limiting the victims of his exploits to minuscule roles – merely serving as instruments to the progression of the show – shows immense disrespect to the victims.

family members of the victims have… criticised the show for its lack of respect to the victims

Giving killers like Dahmer such a heavy spotlight in these types of shows allows the murderer to gain a notorious place in history, securing his legacy and immortalising his acts. For families and communities of the victims, it is a crushing blow to have to re-live the trauma that Dahmer brought upon them and for the producers to barely even recognise their lives and suffering is a severe injustice.

Despite the show’s stated goal being to expose the horrific crimes, ‘centered around the undeserved victims and their communities,’ the show fails to fairly represent the lives of the victims, instead focusing on Dahmer and his horrifying exploits. In response to its release, family members of the victims have criticised the show: Rita Isbell, brother of Errol Lindsey, who was murdered by Dahmer aged 19, criticised the show for its lack of respect for the victims. Eric Perry, a cousin of Lindsey, wrote on Twitter that re-creating scenes with members of their family in without even notifying the families is “cruel”.

It is this insensitivity towards the victims that shows like these must combat if they are to be in some way beneficial to society rather than merely being a money-grab. Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story does an extremely poor job of respecting and honouring the lives of his victims. However, I believe a lesson can be learned from the mistakes that were made by the producers.

shows of this nature must place a greater emphasis on the lives of the victims

First, it is vital that families of the victims are notified when a show of this nature is being published. It shows no respect to the families to release the show without their awareness of re-creations of the tragic events that have haunted their lives. Second, I also believe that the shows should benefit the victims’ families in some sort of way; without a system in place where a certain level of the profits goes to the families, producers can merely make money off tragedies. This is morally abhorrent and is pure greed.

In addition, shows of this nature must place a greater emphasis on the lives of the victims and the significance of the acts on the communities. Reducing their lives to merely their pain and suffering is an injustice for their lives as a whole and what they stood for; having had their lives so cruelly taken from them, shows like Monster should place a greater focus on their stories to secure their legacies and ensure we do not forget their suffering.

If producers are able to show more respect for victims in the manner aforementioned, I believe true crime shows of this nature can continue to be published. There is a clear demand for these shows and, on the premise that they are more sensitive to the lives of the victims, have the potential to be informative and less painful for those affected by killers. However, releasing a show in the same vein as Monster, which focuses almost entirely on the killer and not on his victims, is damaging for those affected and reflects the greed of producers who are only concerned with profiting off a tragedy. These shows should not be tolerated and have no place on a streaming service like Netflix.

Image credits: Anastasia Shuraeva via Pexels