Mining the unknown: could deep sea nodules be vital for oceanic life?
By Saskia Birt
As the urgency to tackle climate change grows, the push to slash greenhouse emissions is accelerating through energy transition and technological innovation. Critical minerals like lithium, copper, cobalt and manganese are required for renewable technologies such as solar panels, wind turbines and rechargeable batteries. But with rising concerns over deforestation and pollution, where will we find these essential resources?
The answer potentially lies in polymetallic nodules at the bottom of the sea, over 3,000 meters deep. These are metal-rich deposits formed of concentric layers of iron and manganese hydroxides around a core. They cover over 70% of the seafloor and collectively weigh an estimated 500 billion tonnes. Mining these resources could boost the economy, reduce fossil fuel emissions, and curb the environmental and human costs of mining on land.
However, deep-sea mining comes with significant environmental risks. Disturbing these ecosystems could harm marine life long-term, disrupting species and delicate oceanic balances. Moreover, as this practice has never been attempted on a large scale, its full consequences remain unknown, raising the possibility of unforeseen and potentially irreversible damage.
Unexpected findings this summer shed new light on deep-sea nodules. A research team led by Andrew Sweetman in the Clarion-Clipperton Zone (CCZ), a vast abyssal plain in the Pacific Ocean, discovered that they play a role in oxygen production. Over a decade ago, Sweetman detected unusually high oxygen levels near these nodules but dismissed the results as improbable. However, when the anomaly reappeared during his research in June 2024, he realised he may have overlooked a groundbreaking discovery.
Mining these resources could boost the economy, reduce fossil fuel emissions, and curb the environmental and human costs of mining on land
Experiments using benthic chamber landers showed that the oxygen levels increased to three times the background concentrations in just two days. This contradicts the consensus and previous studies that there was only oxygen consumption in deep-sea sediments.
A possible explanation for this is seawater electrolysis and the concept of the ‘geo-battery’. The nodules exhibit high voltage potentials, up to 0.95V, which could drive the electrolysis of seawater, splitting the water molecules to produce oxygen and hydrogen. This high potential difference occurs between the different metal ions within the layers of the nodules.
Other potential explanations, such as oxygen diffusion from trapped air bubbles, microbial activity, or chemical reactions, were tested and found unlikely to account for the observed oxygen levels. The discovery of ‘dark oxygen production’ (DOP) suggests that previously unknown mechanisms could be supplying oxygen to deep-sea organisms.
This discovery could also help shape our understanding of life’s origins. Scientists have hypothesised that hydrothermal vents, with their steep chemical gradients and abundant minerals, played a key role in life’s emergence. Deep-sea nodules may have been the previously unrecognised source if oxygen was necessary for this process.
Much remains unknown about the scale of this phenomenon and whether it extends across the seafloor. What is certain, however, is that these findings cast new doubt over the risks of deep-sea mining. If polymetallic nodules are crucial to oceanic oxygen production, extracting them could have profound and irreversible consequences for marine ecosystems. Until research unveils the full picture, mining these resources could unleash irreversible damage to our oceans and climate – a risk we cannot afford to take.
Image: Australian Institute of Marine Science via The Ticker / LTMP

