Middlemarch by George Eliot
By Maciej Matuszewski
I tend not to read a great deal of English language classic literature, so Middlemarch was somewhat a departure for me. However, having heard recommendations from many corners, and always looking for ways to diversify my reading habits, I decided to see what this novel had to offer. It was certainly an interesting experience.
Middlemarch is certainly not one of those works which grabs your interest from the first page. Set in the years around 1830, the novel focuses on the lives of the members of middle class society in and around the fictional town of Middlemarch. As indicated by its subtitle, the work is effectively “a study in provincial life” – serious and religious Dorothea Brooke, urged by her life’s desire to contribute to some great work, decides to marry the aged academic Reverend Casaubon; newly arrived Doctor Lydgate attempts to forge an independent life for himself and reform his profession but finds himself hampered by local prejudice and his own pride; young wastrel Fred Vincy finds himself at a loss with what to do with his life when his prospects of a large inheritance are frustrated, while his sister Rosamond attempts to improve her social position through marriage.

It is not difficult to see many of these concerns, and much of the characters’ focus on status and social hierarchy, as rather petty – not only irrelevant to modern life, but also to the greater concerns of the time when the novel is set. However, it is this very pettiness that eventually wins the reader over. It seems a universal quality that such things often have the greatest personal importance for us. Eliot has a great talent of making even the most arrogant and self-centred individuals seem relatable, by presenting them as real people and showing us that, whether we like it or not, we all share some of their qualities.
This is a true doorstopper of a novel but Eliot uses her word-count well. While there are about a dozen major characters, and countless minor ones, the novel never feels crowded or confused. Its many disparate story lines blend together to create a rich and believable picture of a community. There are no broad brush sketches or caricatures here – few other novels manage to present such a detailed and intimate picture of people’s lives. This depth of characterisation is what makes this novel so powerful – even though they face situations which are often so very different from those that we face we are able to get to understand their fears and frustrations, see past their flaws to the good people that they are trying to be, and maybe even see a little bit of ourselves in them.
It is remarkable that Middlemarch manages to achieve this universal timelessness while still being so heavily concerned with the events of the time in which it is set. The novel presents a fascinating look at a rigidly stratified society being shaken up by political reform and the consequences of industrial revolution. Of particular note is book’s treatment of women. At first glance it seems depressingly of its time, with the goal of most of the female characters being to find a suitable husband. However, a closer consideration reveals several surprisingly progressive elements. Most of the central characters are women, and they all have, in their own ways, a fair amount of agency, even after they are married. Dorothea in particular is far more assertive than women were expected to be at the time and her rejection of the stifling atmosphere created by her marriage to Casaubon, though late in coming, is presented as something positive. Whilst many of the women in the novel do seem to accept their subservience to men, there seems to be a subtle yet strong argument running throughout the novel that this is, in Eliot’s own words, “an imperfect social state”.
Whole essays and books have been written analysing Middlemarch so this review can only ever at best be a cursory glance at this fascinating novel. I do hope, however, that I have managed to inspire you to check it out.
