Michael Hingson: Surviving 9/11 and challenging perceptions of disability

Former Editor-in-Chief William Milne speaks with 9/11 survivor Michael Hingson about his escape from the World Trade Center with his guide dog, Roselle.

By William Milne

Most people over a certain age can recall where they were and what they were doing when the Twin Towers were toppled on 11 September 2001, after two planes were hijacked by al-Qaeda terrorists. Michael Hingson remembers more than most, because he was there, on the 78th floor of World Trade Center One, with his guide dog, Roselle. Together, they escaped, and Roselle would later be recognised for her heroics with the American Hero Dog of the Year Award.

“It was a pretty calm fall day, a typical day in September,” Hingson tells me from his home in California, casting his mind back to the day that was to alter the course of both his life and world history.

▲ Following the attacks, Michael Hingson left his computer business to become a social advocate for change concerning disabilities. He is currently the Ambassador for the National Braille Literacy Campaign of the National Federation of the Blind.

At around 7.45am, “I went to the office because we were going to be doing some seminars that day, teaching some of our partners how to sell our products.” Michael’s colleague from their corporate office, David Frank, arrived at around 8am with a few representatives from Ingram Micro, the distributor that requested the sales seminars.

At 8.46am, however, business stopped.

“The airplane hit the building between floors 93 and 99. It crashed into the building and started pushing it. The building just started tipping and tipping and tipping. We probably moved about 20 feet,” Michael says.

The building just started tipping and tipping and tipping. We probably moved about 20 feet

Mohamed Atta, the ringleader of the attacks, had flown American Airlines Flight 11 into the North Tower. It was the first of four coordinated attacks that would, within an hour, leave nearly 3,000 people dead.

Most of us have listened to those heartbreaking phone calls from 9/11 victims calling family members to tell them they love them very much and may not make it home. Hingson was one of these people staring death in the face. Only, he escaped due to a combination of luck, skill, and a very special canine friend.

“David and I actually said goodbye to each other because we thought we were about to take a 78-floor plunge to the street.” He also called his wife, Karen. However, “the building stopped [tipping] and it started coming back the other way. And finally it got to be vertical again.”

Most would panic in the situation, and most did. However, Hingson knew that they could not afford to lose their composure, since remaining cool-headed is so central to a successful relationship between a blind person and their guide dog. Therefore, Hingson stayed focused, which in turn kept Roselle calm and also focused.

“Her attitude was very important. If she suddenly started to exhibit fear, then I would be very concerned and want to figure out why. We feed off each other and in this case we were both calm. We didn’t exhibit any fear because there was nothing directly for us to be afraid of.”

We feed off each other and in this case we were both calm. We didn’t exhibit any fear because there was nothing directly for us to be afraid of

“Roselle was under my desk asleep when the building was struck, and she stayed there” as the building kept tipping.

I can tell how proud Hingson is of Roselle as he recounts the events of that fateful day. He knows how special Roselle, who passed away in 2011, was. He fondly remembers how her only fear was thunder, and that was just about it, hence the name of Hingson’s book, Thunder Dog, which instantly became a New York Times best-seller upon its release in 2011.

Not everyone shared Hingson and Roselle’s pragmatism. “David turned and looked out of the window and started shouting ‘Oh my God, there’s fire and smoke above us. We have got to get out of here right now. We can’t stay here.’ And I said ‘slow down’ […] I kept telling David to slow down, to stop panicking. Our guests began to scream.”

At approximately 8.50am, five minutes after the plane hit the building, “We just left the office and went to the stairs. And we started down. And then, almost immediately, I began smelling an odor, which was burning jet fuel. And so we assumed that we were hit by an airplane, but we didn’t know why or what.”

It seemed like an unfortunate, possibly tragic, accident, rather than the moment that would mark a new world order. Unbeknownst to Hingson, the world had stopped, and its eyes were fixated on his place of work.

Hingson pauses his narrative to criticise the notion that, as a result of his blindness, he was oblivious to the full extent of what was happening.

Almost immediately, I began smelling an odour, which was burning jet fuel. And so we assumed that we were hit by an airplane, but we didn’t know why or what

“What a stupid statement to make. That is so dumb. When people say that, it just goes to show everything that I’ve said about how sighted people perceive people who are blind. Nobody on my side of the building could see what was going on […] We figured out an airplane hit the building because we smelled the fuel – the fumes from burning jet fuel. But nobody knew what happened anyway.”

Hingson’s frustration is palpable. Yet his story of escape is an overwhelmingly convincing response to such prejudice, because it shows how his relationship with his guide dog and his own observation skills actually played to his advantage.

78 floors is a long way. Hingson says it took 50 minutes for him to get out. 50 very long minutes, no doubt. Soon after he got out, the tower would collapse.

“Going down the stairs, none of us knew what had happened,” he recalls. “There were a couple of burn victims who passed us. And so, we knew that something was going on. Firefighters passed us going the other way. But what we could do was to escape and go downstairs, and that’s what the firefighters told us to do.

“We got to the bottom floor at 9.35am. I checked my watch when we got into the lobby, and it was another 10 minutes before we got outside. So we were outside at about 9.45am.” 

In a matter of minutes, the second tower, World Trade Center Two, collapsed, at 9.59am.

“We were there when Tower Two collapsed and had to run from that […] We were like within 100 yards of this 400-yard-tall building that was collapsing. So, everyone ran and we ended up in the dust cloud and had to get out of that and we discovered an entrance to the Fulton St. subway station. So, we went down into the station. Throughout the whole thing, Roselle, even through that crash, did not have any sort of fear.”

We were like within 100 yards of this 400-yard-tall building that was collapsing. So, everyone ran and we ended up in the dust cloud

Eventually, two minutes after World Trade Center One collapsed, Hingson managed to get hold of his wife, Karen. “She had no idea what was going on regarding me. You know, I called her before we left to go to the stairwell to start down, and then she didn’t hear from me until the tower had collapsed.” 

Hingson got to make that second phone call. Countless others were not so fortunate.

It was a miracle that Hingson escaped. However, he is adamant that the first miracle is not how he got out of the tower, but how he got in there in the first place. He tells me that “the unemployment rate today, among employable blind people, is somewhere in the neighbourhood of 70%. It is not that blind people can’t work. It is that sighted people think blind people can’t work because they can’t see.”

The unemployment rate today, among employable blind people, is somewhere in the neighbourhood of 70%. It is not that blind people can’t work. It is that sighted people think blind people can’t work because they can’t see

The story of Hingson and Roselle is the most compelling answer to this misconception, since Hingson is something of a high achiever. Accompanied by various guide dogs throughout his life, he received an education, ran a computer business that operated out of the World Trade Center, and escaped the greatest tragedy to strike America in recent history.

After the attacks, therefore, Hingson became a social advocate for change concerning disabilities, notably through his involvement with the National Federation of the Blind where he is the Ambassador for the National Braille Literacy Campaign.

In the days and months following 9/11, Hingson and Roselle had “literally hundreds” of television interviews, including multiple appearances on the Larry King Show.

Often, when people experience major trauma, they simply cannot talk about it ever again. I am curious as to why Hingson has felt able to talk about what happened on that day.

“For me, the therapy came from talking to all these reporters and getting everything from very dumb to very smart questions. But then people started calling and saying we want to hire you to come and tell us what we should learn from 11 September and talk to us about leadership and so on.” For Hingson, this sounded a lot more worthwhile than selling computer hardware, and so he became a full-time public speaker.

For me, the therapy came from talking to all these reporters and getting everything from very dumb to very smart questions

As for Roselle, she contracted a disease in 2004, possibly due to toxins ingested at 9/11, but she worked as a guide dog until 2007, and eventually passed away in 2011. Her outstanding approach to tragedy saw her recognised with various awards, including the prestigious Dickin Medal which recognises animals for their bravery, and the American Hero Dog of the Year award. 

“She had a good, long life.” 

An exceptional life, with an exceptional owner. 

She [Roselle] had a good, long life

Hingson’s story isn’t only about 9/11. To see it like that would be reductive and ignorant of what Hingson has been trying to do. He has used 9/11 as a vehicle to speak to the beauty of the relationship between a guide dog and their owner, how the skills they learnt equipped them to survive one of the worst disasters the world has ever known, and why, therefore, so many people have got it so wrong with their ideas about blind people. I cannot help but be in awe of a man who picked up the pieces of this tragedy and did something so positive.

Image credit: Michael Hingson