(Metaphorically) fuelling a fire: Britain’s shortage crisis

By Daniel Aichen

“There is no fuel shortage. I repeat, THERE IS NO FUEL SHORTAGE”. That was the tweet sent out by government minister Nadine Dorris on Friday 24th September. However, with forecourts across the country out of fuel and fights breaking out between desperate individuals, it is reasonable to wonder quite just how we got here. The UK is supposed to be one of the most developed economies in the world but is currently hampered by serious supply chain issues that are increasingly expected to evolve into crises, meaning notable shortages at Christmas are almost guaranteed. 

The government has responded by granting emergency temporary visas to foreign drivers and drafting in the army to drive Heavy Goods Vehicles (HGVs), transporting more fuel around the country. This crisis appears to be subsiding as panic buying has reduced, however parts of the country are still without fuel, particularly the South East of England. It is not that there is a shortage of fuel, instead it is that there is a shortage of HGV drivers, meaning the fuel cannot get where it needs to be. This large gap in the workforce has resulted in a shortage of dozens of products, including fuel, over the last few months, which is expected to continue for the foreseeable future. It is critical we question exactly why this situation has occurred.

The UK is currently short of 100,000 HGV drivers, according to the Road Haulage Association. Many political commentators are blaming Brexit. But how accurate are these claims?

Brexit has certainly had an impact, but this crisis cannot be attributed solely to it

Between 2010 and 2017 EU-born drivers in the workforce steadily grew from 10,000 to 45,000, whilst the number of UK-born drivers remained stagnant. Thus, foreign-born drivers were having increased importance within UK supply chains, especially at times of increased demand. During the pandemic HGV drivers decreased from 304,000 in the first quarter of 2020 to 235,000 in the second quarter of 2021. Post-Brexit immigration changes that removed the rights of EU drivers to live and work in the UK, combined with the Covid-19 pandemic, encouraged many drivers to return to their home country. This increased the pressure on the government to grant temporary visas for drivers within EU countries to work in the UK.

However, of the 70,000 drivers that left the profession during the pandemic, only 12,500 were drivers from EU countries. Brexit has certainly had an impact, but this crisis cannot be attributed solely to it. We need to look closer to home to get a fuller understanding of this shortage.

55,000 domestic drivers left the industry in the last 18 months. The average age of HGV drivers in the UK is 55, whilst less than 1% of the workforce are under 25. This is an ageing workforce that sees 4% of its drivers retire every year. Usually, new entrants will help to offset those leaving but the pandemic has prevented people from obtaining their HGV licences due to a lack of testing during lockdowns. The pandemic has exacerbated an issue that already existed in the industry. 

There are fundamental structural issues that the sector needs to overcome if it is to encourage more drivers back to fill the shortage

Between 2015 and 2019 there were three times as many people passing and obtaining their HGV licence than retirements, meaning HGV drivers should have been increasing each year but this was not the case. 230,000 HGV licence holders under 45 have chosen not to work in the commercial haulage sector, despite spending the £3,000 to obtain the licence. There are fundamental structural issues that the sector needs to overcome if it is to encourage more drivers back to fill the shortage. Working conditions, salary rates and unsociable hours all play a critical role in why people, especially younger people, do not want to enter the workforce.

For now, the government is hoping its 5,000 temporary visas will be enough to plug the gap in the short-term, but this is wishful thinking. EU workers are not likely to be motivated to return for a mere three months to a country that has spent years pushing a narrative that seeks to remove them. The most obvious example of this is the ‘hostile environment’ which began under Theresa May as home secretary, which saw xenophobia and anti-immigrant rhetoric exacerbated. To date only 127 fuel drivers from overseas have applied for a temporary visa, clearly highlighting the notion that foreign workers are not keen to come to the UK whilst visas remain only 3 months.

The government should grant a far higher number of visas for a longer period of at least 12 months to encourage enough drivers back to overcome this crisis in the short-term. However, longer-term structural reform to this industry, supported by government, is critical if we want to encourage enough drivers back to the profession, to plug the gap in the workforce and prevent this happening again in the future.

Image: Simon Burchell via Wikimedia Commons

Support Palatinate