Mercury Music Prize Nominees 2011
The Mercury Prize, the annual ‘best album’ prize, is awarded exclusively each year to bands from the UK and Ireland. Sometimes labelled as a career curse, the prize actually helps raise awareness of lesser known bands, and provides a significant boost in album sales. This year’s nominations were revealed on Tuesday 19th of July, and the current joint favourites are Adele, with her record-busting 21 and PJ Harvey’s Let England Shake.
Adele – 21
It would be difficult to find someone who hasn’t heard of this behemoth of an album, which held the UK number one spot for eleven weeks – the longest running stint for a solo artist ever, and which has sold over 2.5 million copies here. The album was produced by Rick Rubin and is bigger, bolder and more mature than her 2008 debut 19. The brilliant ballad Someone Like You might grate now after months of overplaying but is bound to be remembered for years to come. Presumably nominated because of the great critical reception of 21, Adele doesn’t really need the publicity of a Mercury Prize win, and shouldn’t be disappointed to concede it to someone less well-known.
PJ Harvey – Let England Shake
The oldest artist on the shortlist, the legendary PJ Harvey flexes her war poetry muscles here in the style of a modern day Siegfried Sassoon or Wilfred Owen. ‘I’ve seen and done things I want to forget. I’ve seen soldiers fall like lumps of meat… arms and legs were in the trees’ are the striking opening lines of The Words That Maketh Murder. These songs are also poems trying to galvanise England into a better state. Ever since she appeared in a feathered headdress on the Andrew Marr Show in front of Gordon Brown, then prime minister, singing ‘England’s dancing days are done,’ this album has been one to watch. A series of films by Seamus Murphy for each of the tracks on the album can be found on YouTube which suggest meanings and reveal new interpretations. It’s a completely different sound from her previous Mercury winner Stories from the City, Stories from the Sea. This album’s bursting with creativity and ideas. It’s clear why she’s the favourite to win.
Other nominees include…
Anna Calvi – Anna Calvi
Often misleadingly compared to Florence and the Machine, Calvi’s debut is almost toxically sumptuous, dramatic and dark. The album opens with a skilled instrumental and from then on mixes classical and rock influences. Her voice is versatile – the velvety tones of No More Words contrast with hurricane force of Desire. The most striking about the record is the confidence it displays. It’s not like anything else out at the moment – she’s got the critics on her side and is in with a good chance of the prize.
Elbow – Build a Rocket Boys!
Building upon the runaway success of 2008’s The Seldom Seen Kid (after their Mercury win), Elbow’s latest offering combines creativity and experimentation with their winning cup-of-tea cosiness. Their special brand of emotional rock hasn’t changed too much. The Birds is a long, but enjoyable opener, while Lippy Kids delivers more One Day Like This euphony, lamenting young people’s failure to appreciate and make the most of youth. Neat Little Rows recalls Grounds for Divorce. It’s a great album, and you can’t criticise them for not changing the formula, but it’s perhaps not different enough from previous efforts to deserve a second win.
Everything Everything – Man Alive
This album is dense and complex, but masquerades as quirky pop. Don’t be surprised to find multifarious melodies woven (or grafted) skilfully together into convincing tracks – especially in Schoolin’. The lyrics are interesting, and often bizarre – in MY KZ UR BF the concept of a warzone soap opera is explored, while Photoshop Handsome protests against the techno age with boundless energy. The instrumentation is pleasantly varied – spot the trumpets in Come Alive Diana and space-age synths in Tin (The Manhole). It’s also rhythmically challenging and the final track Weights keeps you on your toes right until the end of the album. Brilliant, cerebral, and completely unique.
Read Palatinate’s review of Everything Everything here!
Ghostpoet – Peanut Butter Blues and Melancholy Jam
You can guess what the album will be like from its cover – the blurry slurred rap is set against a dreamy, or rather nightmarish, mix of electro and dub backing. It’s not a daytime album. On Garden Path, a brief section of birdsong gives the impression he’s been awake all night. The lyrics are the focus – on Survive It, a story of a life gone wrong is speedily and comprehensively delivered, ‘Been shown the door cos they’re talking about cutbacks, you think what next?’ Run Run Run shows his wit ‘Hey, run away, be a real man and fight another day, I heard that in a TV programme, so it must be right, right, right?’ A combination of worry and regret make this album heavy, and it’s very leftfield compared to some other nominations. Then again, Speech Debelle clinched it in 2009…
Gwilym Simcock – Good Days at Schloss Elmau
The obligatory curveball jazz/classical artist, (remember The Kit Downes Trio?) this thirty year old pianist graduated from the Royal Academy of Music with 1st class honours and the Principal’s Prize. He was also awarded the BBC Jazz Rising Star in 2005. He hopes the nomination will open his music up to a wider audience, who he thinks might be ‘frightened of instrumental music.’
James Blake – James Blake
Second in the BBC’s Sound of 2011 List behind the less Mercury-appropriate Jessie J, James Blake’s eponymous debut was an experimental exercise in understated electro. Heir to The xx this year, he holds up the post-dubstep front with his soulful voice. While enjoyable in places, Blake’s album is such hard work that it’s difficult to imagine him winning.
Read Palatinate’s review of this album here!
Katy B – On a Mission
Last year’s hit single Katy on a Mission won the BRIT school and Goldsmiths graduate the UK’s attention alongside her collaboration with Magnetic Man, Perfect Stranger. The 22 year old’s debut cleverly mixes underground and pop music. The album’s crammed with hooks and credible club pop. Commercial, yes, but also smart. The album ends with Hard to Get, listing her thank-yous, laughing. She gives the somewhat faceless world of club music personality and likeability.
King Creosote + John Hopkins – Diamond Mine
This folk album is a collaboration between the Scottish singer-songwriter King Creosote, who is also a member of The Burns Unit, and the Ivor Novello nominated producer and composer Jon Hopkins who has worked with Brian Eno, Coldplay and Imogen Heap. You can hear where Hopkins has filled in the gaps King Creosote leaves, noticeably on the Bubble, with its electronic backing. The mixture of the old and the new is subtle but effective. The remote coastal setting of the album, with its ambient noises of the sea, a bustling cafe, and seagulls give it character, but perhaps not enough to drown out the other entries.
Metronomy – The English Riviera
The stars of many a festival this summer, the Devon band have impressed with their self-described ‘sunset funk’ and pop sensibility. Turning the direction of the band around from Nights Out, singles The Look and The Bay stand out on an album that abounds in cool synth and choral backing. Their live act has some cool flashing chest lights too…
Tinie Tempah – Disc-Overy
Aside from the fact that the title reads rather like Disc Ovary, the breakthrough rapper’s album is great in places. Smart songs Frisky and Pass Out are ubiquitous as ever, and the latter won an Ivor Novello award and a BRIT award. He shows pop sense on Wonderman, his collaboration with famous music buddy Ellie Goulding, but the worse commercial songs (ahem, Written in the Stars, Invincible) leave something of a bad taste when there are highlights like ‘I got so many clothes I keep some in my aunt’s house,’ mocking rappers’ boasts. He lets himself down from these moments of brilliance by complaining how tired he is of press attention and his high quality lifestyle (Let Go). He’s definitely a talent, but he should avoid unappealing and irritating clichés.
The Mercury Prize Awards Show will take place on September 6th.

