Mercury Fur: Censorship does not work

By Will Entwistle

Art needs freedom—and freedom needs art. The director relates to viewers. However, viewers can relate to other viewers. Yet, it is censorship that infringes the viewer’s and director’s freedom.

Art can be seminal, but also destructive. It can unite and polarise. However, censorship of art deemed destructive disempowers us because it prevents engagement with ideas that we can learn from. This does not mean art is irreproachable.

Instead, art should empower us all, regardless of its form, to engage with it and the interpretations of others. In this way, our attitudes must shift from critical reticence to confidence. We should empower others to comment on art because it is, in fact, our prerogative; and thus remove preventative measures, like censorship. How, then, can we react to art that appears offensive and harmful?

Our attitudes must shift from critical reticence to confidence

Often, art worth experiencing is not enjoyable. In fact, it is difficult – confronting poignant social issues is seldom easy. For instance, Phillip Ridley’s Mercury Fur offers an almost apocalyptic perspective of Britain. Ridley depicts a society crippled by fear and corruption where even butterflies have mutated into psychedelic drugs. Initially, Faber & Faber refused to publish Mercury Fur and without explanation. Perhaps it was the profanity, racism, incessant drug-use, and violence.

The degenerate characters appear to speak and act entirely without morality. John Peter summarises, ‘This is not a play you enjoy. It is a play you need to see for its diagnosis of a terror-stricken and belligerent civilisation’. Crucially, Peter clarifies the distinction between art that is worthwhile and enjoyable. Mercury Fur embodies the difficulty of art and yet necessitates our engagement. That is, Ridley intentionally provokes us and invites our participation.

Our reception of Mercury Fur demonstrates that we, as humans, inherently moralise events. In this way, we are, if reluctantly, part of the production because our moral and critical faculties inform Ridley’s calculated account of chaotic deprivation. Mercury Fur is an invitation to engage with issues in a society that seems entirely disconnect to our own, and yet retains deep similarities. It is a cause célèbre.

We, as humans, inherently moralise events

Elsewhere, Stanley Kubrick’s cinematic rendering of Burgess’ novel, A Clockwork Orange, shows censorship can disempower us. The authorities did not ‘ban’ the film. Rather, Kubrick removed the film in the UK amid claims of copycat violence.

Several horrific acts, including murders and rapes, were linked to the film. For instance, a 16-year-old boy in Bletchley murdered an elderly homeless man. A lawyer involved with the case argued ‘the link between this crime and sensational literature, particularly A Clockwork Orange, is established beyond reasonable doubt’. Was it, then, best to remove the film?

A Clockwork Orange’s release in the UK during 2000 suggested otherwise. Crime rates did not spike in response to the film’s release. The sensationalism surrounding the film’s initial release threatened us more than its content. In this sense, the film’s removal did not resolve the further threat of copycat crimes. Moreover, Kubrick’s decision, alongside the authorities’, prevented our collective engagement with A Clockwork Orange. We cannot properly understand what we see if our view is blocked.

We cannot properly understand what we see if our view is blocked

Releasing controversial art always risks uneducated imitation. Comparably, Martin Scorsese’s Taxi Driver presents Travis Bickle’s, played by Robert de Niro, assassination attempt on a presidential candidate. Elsewhere, John Hinckley was inspired by Bickle’s character to shoot Ronald Reagan in 1981. Hinckley’s motive was to impress Jodie Foster, who stars in Taxi Driver as an underage prostitute.

Crucially, Hinckley confused fiction and reality. Yet, does this make Scorsese responsible for the attack? No. Instead, it means Hinckley misunderstood Bickle’s mental plight and conflated heroism with insanity. In essence, Hinckley was deluded.

Here, our engagement with art reminds us that we participate in art. We attempt to relate with the artist’s message and the perception of others. Hinckley’s failed assassination attempt demonstrates that our engagement with film should not come at the expense of others.

Instead, we learn more about our human condition by criticising art because we, in this case, can hold harmful behaviours to account. Censorship denies us the chance to make sense of what we see in both art and reality.

Mercury Fur is being performed at the Assembly Rooms Theatre between Thursday 12th and Saturday 14th March at 19.30. Tickets still available via Durham Student Theatre.

Image credit: Durham Student Theatre