MEQ response rates fall sharply as University seeks to reform process

By Waseem Mohamed

The average response rate for Module Evaluation Questionnaires (MEQs) fell to a new low of 35% last academic year, which represents a 21% drop in the average response rate since MEQs were adopted in their current format in 2017. 

Data obtained by Palatinate through a Freedom of Information request reveals that there has been a downward trend in the number of students who complete their MEQs across all year groups and most subjects. 

It comes as the University is implementing a new MEQ process which is being trialled this academic year, which will see MEQ questions become standardised in a move that hopes to make the evaluation process “smoother and more streamlined for Departments”. 

In the 2017/18 academic year, the average response rate for MEQs across all modules was 56%, but this average has fallen every year since. It fell to 51% in 2018/19 and 48% in 2020/21, before reaching a new low of 35% last year. MEQs were mostly cancelled in the 2019/20 academic year as a result of the Covid-19 pandemic, with MEQs that year only being conducted for modules that finished before December 2019. 

With an average response rate of 51.5%, first-year students are more likely to complete MEQs compared to second-year (47.25%) and third-year (46%) students, but across all year groups the average MEQ response rate has fallen significantly. Among first and second-year students, the average response rate fell 19% between 2017/18 and 2021/22, while for third-year students it fell by 23%. 

When comparing averages by subject, it was found that students studying Sport Sciences had the lowest MEQ average response rate at just 32% over the past five years. Other subjects with low average response rates included Business (33%) and Economics (35%), while Education had the highest average response rate at 56.75%. 

Across many subjects, there has been a substantial drop-off in the average MEQs response rate in the past five years, with Japanese having the largest drop-off between 2017/18 and 2021/22 with the average response rate falling by 45%. 

The data also reveals the number of modules each year that saw a perfect 100% MEQ response rate as well as the number of modules that had a 0% response rate. In 2017/18, no fewer than 20 modules had a 100% response rate compared to just five modules with a 0% response rate, but by 2021/22 this trend had flipped so that only seven modules had a 100% response rate, compared to 17 modules with a 0% response rate. 

One former subject representative spoke to Palatinate about their experience of MEQs. They said that the trends in response rates could be “due to apathy”, with “students feeling like it’s either pointless or like things won’t be taken on board” by doing the MEQs. They also suggested the timeframe that students are given to complete MEQs is too short and does not “give people much chance to fill them in”. 

The subject rep said that they liked doing MEQs, but claimed that they are only good “for improvements that students will not see the results of”. They suggested that for modules which span across the full year, an evaluation survey should be issued to students every term rather than at just the end of the module, as this would help locate issues “that aren’t brought to light until after the module is finished”. 

They noted that in their department, some lecturers were doing their own surveys midway through the year which has helped identify specific issues with the way modules were being taught and were hence more effective overall.   

According to Durham University, MEQs “provide quantitative and qualitative evidence concerning the student educational experience” across modules, with students asked to complete a survey to provide feedback on the way their modules were taught for a given year. The University is now seeking to change how MEQs work this year as part of the delayed implantation of the Evaluation and Teaching Excellence senate paper released in 2020. 

In the proposal documents seen by Palatinate, several issues with the current MEQ process were identified, including a “lack of in-built resilience” and how “the dates for MEQ evaluations fall at inopportune times for Departments”, with staff raising concerns that this “results in students evaluating exams rather than the overall teaching of the module”.

“students feel like it’s either pointless or like things won’t be taken on board”

The new MEQ process would see the handling of surveys transferred to the Academic Office, with a pilot scheme running this year. MEQs will be standardised and will run over fixed periods across the academic year in order to help departments integrate MEQ evaluations into their calendars more easily. 

MEQs will also be released at times where they do not overlap with exam periods. For undergraduates this means MEQs will be released in the last two weeks of Michaelmas and Epiphany terms depending on the module length, with the evaluation periods for postgraduates scheduled for either January, June or August.

However, student representatives in the Arts and Humanities faculty have called for further changes to MEQs in light of the low response rates. In a recent minutes of a faulty meeting seen by Palatinate, student reps were “keen for mechanisms to be put in place to make accessing and completing the MEQs quicker and more intuitive”, such as integrating MEQs with the Learn Ultra site rather than running them as standalone surveys, and allowing students to complete an MEQ over multiple sittings. 

Responding to Palatinate’s findings, a Durham University spokesperson said: “MEQs are one of the ways that students can provide feedback on modules. They are open at the end of the module to gather holistic feedback. Information from the MEQs is used to improve modules for future cohorts of students. 

“However, students are also encouraged to provide feedback to teaching staff during modules, either in teaching sessions, in office hours, or through Student Staff Consultative Committees. Feedback given in these ways can be acted upon in-year to make improvements for students currently taking modules. 

“We would encourage all students to fill out MEQs, as they are an important aspect of student voice, which feeds into continuous improvement of modules.”

Image: Durham University