Men of the people?
Like the sasquatch, yeti or Loch Ness monster, the suitability of MPs’ backgrounds is a recurring and contested debate.
Ok fine, perhaps interest in cryptids is wavering, but Tony Blair’s latest interview with The Independent confirms that at least the latter is not. In a mordant swipe at today’s MPs, the former prime minister said that there was a “general problem” in Western democracies with careerists who have never worked outside of the political sphere. The current Middle East envoy then went on to suggest that politicians would do well to work “normal” jobs for several years before heading to Westminster.
Admittedly, the argument is clichĂ©d, but it is not without substance. Consider the social pedigree of our incumbent; David Cameron and Nick Clegg went to private schools whose fees now outstrip the average yearly wage; and after Oxbridge, while still in their 20s, were both “special advisers” to political figures – Cameron to Tory chancellor Norman Lamont and Clegg to Tory Euro commissioner, Leon Brittan.
The opposition is nowhere near as posh; Labour leader Ed Miliband received his schooling at a comprehensive (in well-heeled North London), but did graduate from Oxford and was soon working for Gordon Brown.
But it’s not private education or the Oxbridge de rigueur that Blair takes issue with – after all, he had both himself. Rather, it’s the potential unawareness that such isolated conditioning can incur.
Mr Blair said: “I advise any young person who wants to go into politics today: go and spend some time outside. Go and work for a community organisation…do anything that isn’t politics for at least several years. And then, when you come back into politics, you will find you are so much better able to see the world and how it functions properly.”
It’s a rallying cry that has been around for some time, but at the height of electoral disengagement, the need for greater empathy and concordant expertise has never been so high. In 2013, we run the risk of seeing policy without politics if our MPs are not versed with the very issues with which they charged to deal.
This brings me neatly to Michael Gove. The MP for Surrey Heath became the Secretary for State Education in 2010, despite never having worked in any school in his life.
For evidence of Gove’s incongruity, we need not look any further than his reforms. The purge of re-sits or AS levels augments the pressure on pupils and staff alike, ignoring the possibility of any unfortunate circumstance. Coupled with the elimination of coursework, Gove has created a rigid system that will only serve to benefit a select few. The logic behind the ‘one shot only’ reform is interesting to say the least. Gove reckons it will deter crammers, but I say if anything it’ll encourage them, if there’s nothing riding on first year.
Similarly ill qualified is the Secretary for State Health, Jeremy Hunt. Hunt is not a former doctor, nurse, paramedic or even hospital porter; but don’t worry, he was Head Boy at The Charterhouse School and studied PPE at Oxford.
In fairness to Gove and Hunt though, they both had careers before politics, as a journalist and management consultant respectively; which I suppose exempts them from the initial Blairite critique. What it doesn’t do, however, is exempt them from my own gripe, which is one step further.
I agree with Blair that a career before politics is an absolute must, but I’ll raise the bar and suggest that you should have a proven expertise in the field you wish to engage. Is it unreasonable to suggest that education policy should be determined by those who have actually taught it? You wouldn’t apply to be a Maths teacher if you’d studied History, so why would you trust someone with no medical background to make decisions on the NHS?
Before I conclude, I feel the need to clarify my position on private schools, lest any of the thinner skinned libertarians get upset. There’s nothing wrong with a private education. Almost invariably, these schools produce the best results and some of the brightest minds in the country, but it should not be overlooked that they are available to only 7%of the current population. Aspiring politicians would do well to have some interaction with the general public before they even think about representing them. Of course, I’m not calling for the next batch of Etonians to spend their summers in a supermarket; I’m simply asking that requisite for parliament be something more than a 2.1 from Magdalen College.
Photograph: Nick Dugan

