Memories of the Holocaust

By Charlotte Kume-Holland

“The Baby born in a concentration camp”

Mother and daughter – Anna and Eva (right to left)

Recently, Durhamprobono Society organised for Holocaust survivor Eva Clarke to speak at the Debating Chambers about her mother’s experiences and their survival of the Holocaust. Her talk was very well received by all who attended, and moved people both in terms of her story and her message for future generations.

So Eva Clarke is “a survivor- but only just.” Why? Because incredibly, Eva was actually born in the Mauthausen concentration camp in Austria, on 29th April 1945- making her both a first and second generation survivor. Their survival, which Eva puts down to a mixture of luck, her mother’s determination and a glass of milk, is unbelievable, and Eva discussed the close encounters they had with death.

In December 1941 Eva’s mother and father were sent to Terezin, a ghetto just outside Prague. Their youth and strength meant they were able to work, ensuring that they stayed in the ghetto for 3 years. Despite the sexes being separated, Anna fell pregnant. However, when the baby was born, he died of pneumonia before being handed to the Gestapo to be killed. This however meant the preservation of Anna’s and eventually Eva’s lives, because Anna and her husband were next sent to Auschwitz-Birkenau on 1st October 1944, and had she arrived with a baby, they would immediately have been gassed. Tragically this was the last time she saw her husband, but unbeknown to him she was pregnant again with Eva.

For six months she worked as a labourer, becoming gradually weaker and more heavily pregnant. In April 1945 as the Nazis retreated, Eva’s mother and her fellow prisoners faced a three week nightmare journey around the Czech countryside. The train arrived at Mauthausen concentration camp on 29th April 1945, where the shock of seeing the name of this notorious camp sent Anna into labour. Without any type of medical assistance Eva was born on an open cart. Ordinarily both would have been immediately gassed, however once again luck was on their side, as the gas chamber at Mauthausen was blown up on 28th April 1945, the day before they arrived. The camp was liberated three days later.

Eva was actually born in the Mauthausen concentration camp in Austria, on 29th April 1945- making her both a first and second generation survivor.

As the only survivors from their immediate family, Eva and her mother have worked with the Holocaust Educational Trust (HET) for many years, speaking in schools, universities and prisons- inspiring people with their story. The reason she can do this is because The Holocaust represents more than just an event on a timeline for a history student. It strikes a chord with people. Why? Because it can be used as a metaphor for contemporary issues; racism, discrimination and morality, things which contemporary genocides such as Rwanda prove still exist in society today.

Eva explains how “they changed what it meant to be human”– and with the prejudice which still exists, this could very easily still happen. This is why the HET work as hard as they do, running their outreach programmes to ensure as many people hear the powerful testimonies of a survivor as possible.  It is imperative that these messages are instilled in people from a young age, because the amount of young people we’ve engaged with who know little to nothing of the Holocaust is both surprising and disappointing. Among HET’s earliest achievements was ensuring that the Holocaust formed part of the National Curriculum for History. Their focus is on Lessons Learnt from the Holocaust, and they encourage the students who participate in the project to adopt an ambassador role as we did. When you’ve seen and experienced the power of Auschwitz first hand, you don’t forget it in a hurry.

There are several HET ambassadors at Durham. Mel Page from Mary’s said of her experience: “I was fortunate enough to have the awe-inspiring opportunity to participate in the HET’s ‘Lessons from Auschwitz’ project. The programme highlighted the importance of active citizenship, and has taught me to speak out against intolerance and to think about the dangers of prejudices and discrimination”.

Eva raised many interesting points regarding the ways in which the Holocaust is now remembered. In her opinion, “Schindler’s list is perfect” in terms of Holocaust teaching, compared to The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas which “has its place but is extremely unrealistic and just could not have happened”. However, surely some knowledge is better than none at all? She agreed, noting that the main thing which survivors of the Holocaust agree upon is the importance of maintaining interest in the younger generations. If the only way this can be done for some is through partly fictional films, then so be it. Eva’s wish is to “keep the memory alive”, which is why she, along with other survivors, still work tirelessly to get this message across, even in their 80’s and 90’s.

The Holocaust was tragic. However, “six million murdered” in many ways is so incomprehensible that it becomes just a number. Therefore, as Daniel from Trevelyan puts it, “having somebody actually tell such a personal story makes all the difference to how the Holocaust is remembered, because it is the personal stories which really keep it alive”.

Photographs: Eva Clarke and Clementine Smith