Meat tax: notorious, noxious… necessary?

By Emer McGovern

We all need to eat less meat. Given the insurmountable research laid before us about the benefits of a plant-based diet for the environment, our health and animal welfare this fact is essentially indisputable.

The National Diet and Food survey revealed that meat consumption has already fallen by 17% in the last decade, yet this falls below the targets of the National Food Strategy to ensure food security in face of a growing, ageing population.
Vegetarian diets also tend to be a lot cheaper with a University of Oxford study suggesting it is up to a third cheaper and much closer to home, the cheapest of cheapskates, students, are two times more likely to be vegetarian than the general population. However, despite Gen-Z and Millennials being more sustainability-orientated, a poll prior to the COP26 summit showed that eco-anxiety transcends race, class and gender. The climate crisis is inescapable.

So, when Claire Coutinho, Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero stipulated Labour was planning on implementing a meat tax, a politician making claims about an opposition party’s policies was for once, believable. Animal advocates rejoice! Carnivore diet fanatics – your food bill is potentially going to get very expensive. Everyone else buy that sirloin steak while your pockets still allow it.

Students are two times more likely to be vegetarian than the general population

On the 2nd of October at the Conservative Party Conference she stated, rather coyly, ‘It’s no wonder that Labour seems so relaxed about taxing meat. Keir Starmer doesn’t eat it and Ed Miliband is clearly scarred by his skirmish with a bacon sandwich.’ Funny she didn’t mention Boris Johnson’s encounter with a bacon sandwich.

In response, Labour has confirmed that taxing meat is not a party policy and Ms Coutinho explained in a Sky News interview that she believed Labour’s sentiment to ‘discourage people from eating meat’, meant meat taxation. A politician caught lying again. Shock.

Regardless of all the he-said-she-said, should we be considering a meat tax as part of a greener and healthier future? The main concerns are whether it would significantly change purchasing patterns, if it will disproportionately affect some members of society more than others, and where the money will go. The ongoing cost of living crisis also raises questions as to the fairness of further increasing food costs.

Although the mechanisms of how exactly a meat tax would work are unknown, a study posted in the Review of Environmental and Economics Policy suggested that in order to offset the environmental cost of meat production, retail price would have to increase by a minimum of 35% for beef, 25% for poultry and 19% for lamb.

This level of increase would incentivise a reduction in meat consumption of about 2 portions per week in high income countries such as the UK. Furthermore, a 2018 study claimed, ‘a health tax on red and processed meat could prevent more than 220,000 deaths and save over $40 billion in healthcare costs every year.’

As brilliant as this sounds, there has been uproar about the prospect from the farming industry and households already struggling with food bills forcing people to consider if meat tax implementation can be carried out without throwing farmers and poorer households into bankruptcy. Many solutions have been proposed to avoid this including, using meat tax revenue to lower the prices of vegetables and grains as well as compensating farmers and rewarding the practice of sustainable and organic farming over battery farms and high-density herds.

A 2018 study claimed ‘a health tax on red and processed meat could prevent more than 220,000 deaths … every year’

Whether this would successfully mitigate the inequalities this taxation may introduce into society is up for debate. It is suggested the buying habits of wealthier households may not change, instead meat would become a commodity for the rich, and an infringement on the consumer rights of the poor with meat consumption itself becoming another way to divide, categorise and marginalise members of society.

Despite the potential benefits of this taxation, as the Labour Party hastily confirmed, a meat tax does not appear to be on our horizon anytime soon. So, what are the next steps in environmental policy, and disturbingly even more importantly, what are the government likely to propose without fearing public backlash and loss of voter solidarity?

With Rishi Sunak indicating the Conservative Party may abandon or delay green policies that increase costs for the consumer and Keir Starmer reluctant to fully support the expansion of ULEZ out of fear of losing constituencies, the balance between trying to uphold voter solidarity and making meaningful, definitive changes is, in my opinion, swinging the wrong way.

The climate crisis is not going away anytime soon, and we are at the precipice of that magic number, 1.5°C. The duty of individuals to fight climate change is not inconsequential but with just 100 companies producing 71% of global emissions, it is clear policy changes are the way forward, and aggressive ones at that. It is time for political parties to bite the bullet, stop tiptoeing around issues and begin making real changes for our sake and the sake of our future.

Image: Kyle Mackie via Unsplash