Matthew Hedges: “They didn’t want to believe the truth”
By Ella Catherall and Jamima Westermann
While the media storm around him is starting to settle, the recovery process for Durham academic Matthew Hedges and his family is just beginning. “I’m going through a process to heal mentally” he says, and admits a hard battle lies ahead. “I already had anxiety beforehand, but it was exacerbated by the situation,” he explains. “It’s going to take months”.
I’m going through a process to heal mentally… it’s going to take months
Matthew spent all but three days of his time in prison in solitary confinement. It was “just a room, no light, no natural air”, lit only by “dentist lights” and with no forms of distraction. It was only after a brief stint in hospital after thoughts of self-harm and suicide that they allowed Matthew something to occupy him, putting a TV in his room and giving him books to read. However, as Daniela points out, these were only very minimal distractions that “nearly end up replacing human contact.”
Matthew’s time in prison was also mentally exhausting, as he had to practically construct a double life in order to appease the authorities, deciding that to make it ‘easier’ he would “go along with whatever they wanted me to say.” It’s this that appeared to have the greatest impact on Matthew: “it feels like my head’s on fire” he began, “I need to put it in snow to get rid of all the steam.”
It feels like my head’s on fire. I need to put it in snow to get rid of all the steam.
Convinced Matthew was a spy, “they were postulating the ranks saying are you a second lieutenant, first lieutenant, major, captain?” to which Matthew felt all he could do was give them what they wanted: “Sure, I’m a captain”, he told them.
Matthew constructed the identity they believed he had: having to remember “every detail in my head” from his emails and thesis, to try and match up with the ‘evidence’ they claimed they had. Every answer Matthew gave was a calculated effort “so they can back it all up and say we’ve got this piece of evidence, he said this in the interview, so this is correct.”
When asked if he thought they believed his stories, he had “no clue.” Even when Matthew offered the truth – that his wife Daniela was Colombian, for example – they refused to believe it: “How can an MI6 agent have a foreign wife?” they asked. Matthew realised the truth was going to get him nowhere: “They didn’t want to believe the truth.”
That’s when you really question due process. Though there’s never been due process.
This decision followed him into the courts, as Matthew explains his reasoning for falsely confessing to spying for MI6 while in the UAE. Telling the truth would cause him to perjure himself, doubtlessly leading to prison time, and so he decided to confess, “once I started that was it, there was no turning back.”
Matthew’s sentencing lasted less than five minutes, and was spoken entirely in Arabic. Surrounded by four armed guards, Matthew understood only what the interpreter chose to explain. The confirmation of his guilty verdict was followed by a sentencing of both life imprisonment and deportation. Confused by how that could be, Matthew asked, “how did that work? But they just repeated it.”
With Matthew taken from the courtroom through one exit, and his family through another, he was “blindfolded, handcuffed in a blacked-out car” and started to recognise the bumps in the road which, rather than prison, were leading back to the same interrogation room he had been in before.
Everyday we’ve had people stopping us in the street and saying we’re so happy to see you back.
“That’s when you really question due process” Daniela adds, “though there’s never been due process.”
When Matthew was eventually released, he “didn’t want to take anything to heart” until he was on the plane, and that plane was in the air. Even now though, Matthew claims he is “still on edge, all the time” and is trying to come to terms with what happened to him: “when I can’t sleep, I watch Dani in the news and people speak about it… I need to understand the extent and level to which it came and the level of support it has driven.”
Matthew and Daniela were overwhelmed by the support they received, both from the community at Durham and from academics around the world. “The community has been amazing” Daniela says, “they mobilised the University to be more outspoken about the situation”. They believe there is an “institutional issue across all UK universities” that needs to be addressed, however. “They waited for Matt to get a life in prison sentence” Daniela explains, “before they were full-on, ‘he’s innocent’”.
No-one is exempt from these stories. It’s just like cancer- it’s a thing that happens to others, but it doesn’t to you, until it happens to your mother, or your siblings, or your grandparents.
They found the organisation of support from the general public “incredible”, however. “Everyday we’ve had people stopping us in the street and saying we’re so happy to see you’re back”, Matthew explains. They’re kind of proud, and that makes me feel even prouder”. As well as 700 prominent academics pledging their support, over 250,000 people worldwide signed a petition to get Matthew home after he was sentenced, which he admits was an “insane” achievement over such a short amount of time.
Matthew was completely in the dark about this campaign while in solitary confinement however, and first heard from the British Embassy only after “six or seven weeks”. “It was such a relief to know that I wasn’t by myself”, he explains.
While the embassy was helpful, the “British government as a whole” could have done more, they believe. Although Matthew’s was an isolated case, it “could have happened to anyone”, Daniela points out, and explains there is a need for the British public to question the procedure used in cases like these. “No-one is exempt from these stories” Daniela says. “It’s just like cancer – it’s a thing that happens to others, but it doesn’t to you, until it happens to your mother, or your siblings, or your grandparents.”
It’s about justice really. It’s about setting a precedent.
Matthew and Daniela now find themselves at the start of a long road to justice. Matthew was pardoned by the UAE, not acquitted, so is still officially deemed guilty, and is responsible for making sure his name is cleared. They are taking on a legal case to fight the impact Matthew’s conviction is having on his academic legitimacy and his abilities to continue his research abroad. “It will be an expensive and lengthy process”, they explain, and as well as seeking support from benefactors, they have started a fundraiser to help cover the immense legal costs. “It’s about justice, really” Daniela explains. “It’s about setting a precedent.”
When asked whether he’ll continue his PhD among the chaos however, Matthew is clear he will see it through. “One hundred percent I’ll finish my thesis” he says, “I can’t stop now!”
“It’s part of fighting for justice, too”, Daniela adds, “Finishing what got you into trouble to begin with”.
Photograph: Daniela Tejada
