Master of the House: Have movies made the most of musicals?

File created with CoreGraphics

By Andy Earnshaw

I’m not sure if you’ve heard, but they’ve made Les Misérables into a movie. The longest continuously running musical’s reincarnation recently secured 3 Oscars out of its 8 nominations. Not bad for a show that was criticised for being ‘overly sentimental’ after a lukewarm opening night all those years ago. There is no doubt that movies of great musicals are a shoo-in success. Any movie would be ecstatic with 8 shots at an Oscar and consider Mamma Mia, which outsold Titanic. But as pieces of entertainment, do they actually work?

Let’s get the real elephant out of the room. A great musical is brilliant songs backed up by a good story. In that order. Do the movies do justice to the music when they almost exclusively choose actors who can act over singers who can sing?

No.

Gerard Butler had never sung until he gotthe part as Erik in The Phantom of the Opera and he was one of the better singers. Attempts by Pierce Brosnan to croon his way through ‘When All Is Said and Done’ are nothing short of embarrassing to listen to. Even Les Misérables falls victim to actors attempting songs that are beyond their reach. Russell Crowe’s attempt at ‘Stars’ lacks all of the grandeur of Phillip Quast’s version, leaving it a little limp at times. And don’t even get me started on the movie’s version of ‘Bring Him Home.’

I’ll leave the examples there; we could fill a page with them. Apart from some notable exceptions (Anne Hathaway, take a bow) the songs are relegated to a tool for storytelling rather than being the pinnacle of dramatic moments or moving insights into the characters’ souls. If I don’t enjoy the soundtrack post-film, I feel that something has been missed.

Speaking of Russell Crowe however, he was the only one to make this heart of stone tremble. His portrayal of Javert’s total belief in the rightness of the law being questioned and then ultimately destroyed was one of the most profound and moving parts in a film that makes its money on moving profundity. To sing/speak so much of his part makes for poor listening, but great watching. That is the magic of movie-musicals.

There is no point decrying musicals being made into movies. The rewards are too huge for those willing to give it a go

When you sit down to watch a movie-musical you have to expect it in that order. A movie first, liberally dashed with songs. When one accepts this, one starts to see genius in the place of demagoguery and shameless cashing-in. ‘Bring Him Home’ is still awful, but because of the movie’s failure to build rapport between Valjean and Marius, it is out of place in the story. ‘Stars’ on the other hand is unsatisfying on the soundtrack, but becomes a quiet vow of determination when Russell Crowe acts it. The movie takes its cinematography to Oscar levels with the echo of this certainty in Javert’s final moments.

Mamma Mia does something similar. Meryl Streep’s ‘Money, Money, Money’, whilst half-decent, is not something you would give a Tony to, but we already know her character and in three minutes we learn an awful lot about her situation and sleep-time solutions. Add to this its comedy and the depth it gives to her two partners in crime and you have a perfect movie song; not a wondrous vocal performance, but a new way of acting that is refreshing and addictive.

I also think that this is the issue with The Phantom of the Opera, a movie with some very good musical performances (for actors at least, see ‘All I Ask of You’ and its reprise). Whilst the songs and orchestration are consistently good – indeed the soundtrack is excellent – the acting is almost entirely poor. There is no connection to the characters; Christine is annoyingly depressed in the film, whereas on stage she goes from being a bright and talented girl to one haunted by an increasingly terrifying maniac. The rest of the film’s cast are just wooden foils upon which Gerard Butler may cast his dark presence.

There is no point decrying musicals being made into movies. The rewards are too huge for those willing to give it a go. We’ll have Wicked on our screens soon enough. They’ll never quite manage what the stage show does though. It might be the same story but it comes across so very differently. This is best summed it in the character of Marius. The musical leaves him as just a bit of a wimp (by Michael Ball’s own admission). However, the movie gave space to allow Eddie Redmayne to develop another side to the character. If we are going to be stuck with subpar music, let us at least insist on this: that the adaptations should use this other medium to expose different facets of the story so that film and show may feed into each other and create a richer story as a whole.

Illustration: James Crosland-Mills